Fan Base: Archived: Kelly Clarkson (#1) - Page 3251

Mhs90

Quote:

Originally posted by MJ Boston

SOURCE

Not me having a heart attack and believing it until I read "Kellegendary"

JClarkSTAN

Ok I'm kinda here for her being a judge on Idol. I don't think it would flop in ratings and her being on tv every week would be AMAZING publicity for the next era.

Quote:

Originally posted by KevinKDC

This makes no sense at all. Why would Jennifer care if Kelly joins or not

Quote:

Originally posted by dancepopCC

Because she knows it will flop without Kelly

Yea basically. Jennifer isn't gonna join Idol unless an A List Idol alumni joins with her. If flop Idols were all judges with her then it would flop. lol

rivers

Ugh I don't know why I'm getting my hopes up for this!! Idol just barely ended. It's too soon to be announcing new judges. I feel like they're just putting stories out to milk out the show.

vonno

Quote:

Originally posted by dancepopCC

Because she knows it will flop without Kelly

Too right.

I'd only watch if Kelly, Carrie & J-Hud were on it. Power trio

calamt

i really hope this is true but it jus sounds too good to be

Bloo

Hasn't she said a few times she doesn't like the idea of "judging" but she would only want to be a mentor?

Mhs90

Quote:

Originally posted by Bloo

Hasn't she said a few times she doesn't like the idea of "judging" but she would only want to be a mentor?

Yes, but producers of the show discussed a total revamping of the show format. It's possible that judges will now have mentoring opportunities and that's what made Kelly sway a bit? Who knows.

JClarkSTAN

Quote:

Originally posted by Bloo

Hasn't she said a few times she doesn't like the idea of "judging" but she would only want to be a mentor?

Yes, which is why I didn't think she would ever do it. But I think the format might be interesting to her and they could convince her to do it. She also once said she wouldn't do a GH album until she's 50 and look what happened. lol

Bloo

Quote:

Originally posted by JClarkSTAN

Yes, which is why I didn't think she would ever do it. But I think the format might be interesting to her and they could convince her to do it. She also once said she wouldn't do a GH album until she's 50 and look what happened. lol

Well let's keep our fingers crossed. I would actually go back to watching AI if she was on it. At least on Idol she couldn't make the contestants look awful like she did on Duets.