Banned
Member Since: 10/28/2011
Posts: 21,283
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Javan
1. Nonsense. When Tamar can hit higher notes while Bey is struggling you scream "they have different timbres!!" but you mocked Tamar's lower register for being "airy". Which is ironic, seeing as Beyonce is singing Halo, her "sound" is just as hollow!
2. Pregnancy affects everyone differently. And yes she also lipped in 2011 too!
3. That video was so dry, I kinda cringed. How do ya'll sit through her feeling her puss like this?  The melismas are always the same! Its ok to have a signature, every good singer has one. But after all these years she still can't think up something different? And trill is like the most basic kind of melisma you can get (on its own)!
I mean don't get me wrong, she is a very good technical singer, and easily the best out of pop girls. But put her up against real RnB/Gospel singers and she's basic.
And on top of that, she stays doctoring her live vocals. I actually wonder what her bare chest voice sounds like. It's a mystery. I mean just watch the last 60 seconds of this video.. Why is her reverb so strong?! Why is it that in her Tidal exclusive "Die With You" the mic is a big as her head? For what. She's got you fooled. You think that her vocals are cohesive and "untouchable" but in reality she uses effects to compensate her lackluster headvoice.
|
- You continue to demonstrate how little you know about voice. I'm no expert but you don't know damn ****.
 "Soprano" and "mezzo-soprano" are not 'timbres'. A timbre is a SOUND, timbre refers to the QUALITIES OF A SOUND. 'Soprano' is a VOICE TYPE. One's VOICE TYPE can be determined by their TIMBRE, but also by their TESSITURA (most comfortable and beautiful sounding part of the range), the WEIGHT and SIZE of their voice, and many other things.
Quote:
|
When Tamar can hit higher notes while Bey is struggling you scream "they have different timbres!!"
|
No dumbo. I SAAAIIIDDD THEY HAVE DIFFERENT VOICE TYPES. I SAID Beyonce's voice is LOWER than Tamar's. Tamar has NATURAL ease higher in her range than Beyonce does, because her voice is NATURALLY HIGHER than Beyonce's. She is not technically better than Beyonce or any more gifted. HER VOICE IS JUST DIFFERENT FROM HERS!
*READING COMPREHENSION CHECK
I never even once mentioned tone color or sound quality, so I don't know why you're even bringing up a timbre.
- Off this irrelevant lipping debate.
- You are not going to sit here and imply that Beyonce always sings the same riffs or can't sing different ones. That's SO ignorant. You just don't know anything about her and I can't sit here and educate you on her life. Does Beyonce perform the same arrangements of her songs sometimes - yes, but that's neither here nor there.
Quote:
|
I mean don't get me wrong, she is a very good technical singer, and easily the best out of pop girls. But put her up against real RnB/Gospel singers and she's basic.
|
- You don't know what you're talking about and you're pulling stuff out of your ass! WHAT 'real R&B/Gospel' singers? If their technique is not where Beyonce's is, if their sound isn't open and resonant and free like Beyonce's is, if their musicality is not at Beyonce's level, then THEY'RE basic.
Tamar simply DOES NOT KNOW how to do what Beyonce does. She is not matched in skill. Sorry.
- Beyonce's lows in "Halo" are full and clear as day. No idea what you're talking about, because she's been flexing that solid, full, clear lower range all over the BEYONCE album and era.
- Beyonce her head voice game:
https://youtu.be/jzBO618M7xI?t=2m37s
|
|
|
|
um