Voting will count 40% of your final score. Save your favorite four and vote off four.
Team Cheryl
Taylor Swift
Cheryl:
She doesn't has the best single covers and this one is by far one of her best ones
Simon:
Are you sure this is her best single cover? i don't see nothing special about it
Nicole:
It’s not a bad single cover. It’s not like I hate anything, but I don’t like anything (beside her lipstick colour). Very simplistic and overall bland.
Miley:
This is not fierce at all. Taylor just looks like she has a blank stare and she looks like a mental hospital patient that can't speak in this photo. If I were you I would have sent the WANEGBT cover.
Madonna:
Um. I don't find her fierce at all but this entry is good compared to the others.
Sky:
This is perfect. Just hot af. I only don't like her creepy hand. It looks weird and stops this from being a 10/10. I would have cropped that scary ass ****.
Rihanna
Cheryl:
PERFECT
Simon:
It's not amazing and i'm sure Rihanna has better single covers but she looks hot
Nicole:
I love it. The colour palette, the dress just held, the field she’s in. I just love it all!
Miley:
Raggedy Ann called. She wants her weave back. In addition, Rihanna looks like Samantha Bonnell from Disappeared here and Samantha's hair was horrible. Bleh.
Madonna:
I love the loud era Iconic look btw
Sky:
It's nice. It's cute. It just doesn't feel very special, but besides some minor things that irk me it's a very strong single cover. Iconic even?
Little Mix
Cheryl:
How Ya Doing is a 70’s songs, that’s why their outfits are so messy. Shame that only a few got it
Simon:
Their faces aren't with the right expression but i like the concept and the colours on the cover
Nicole:
Again nothing really stands out. Yeah it’s pop artish, cartoony but fierce….not really. The only one that vaguely looks fierce is Perrie.
Miley:
PERFECT choice You are doing well in this competition!
Madonna:
Um.
Sky:
Team Simon
Madonna
Cheryl:
I can’t believe that she won, not with this mess.
Simon:
Not a good choice but at least the cover is related to the title
Nicole:
It’s a really brilliant single cover. I think it’s very fierce but is missing something. It’s got all the components of something that could be good, but needed just a little something as some people might see it lame, I don’t though!
Miley:
The artwork and everything is very fancy and nice, but I just feel a bit of a disconnect from Madonna here, sorry.
Madonna:
he has like 70 singles and this is the best single cover you could find?
Sky:
TERRIBLE. Everything about this is awful. I don't understand. That "material girl" font thankfully got left behind in that decade.
Girls Aloud
Cheryl:
***Flawless
Simon:
They look FIERCE the colours are amazing and they look amazing
Nicole:
I had this criticism last time. Everything is amazing, clean and fierce but the one huge thing that stops it getting ten is the god awful background. However, everything else is so bloody perfect it had to just be short of perfection. Well done!
Miley:
Their pose is fierce, but the colors are just clashing and it looks very distorted and gross tbh. Whoever thought it was a good idea to have bright pink dresses set to a pee yellow background must have been drunk.
Madonna:
The same single cover from last season Is this the only fierce single cover they have or smth? It's amazing tho.
Sky:
I love/hate/love the blue arms. They feel special, but still are a BIT odd. Luckily seeing this after the LM one makes this one more special though!
Team Miley
Beyonce
Cheryl:
Let me call Peta, this *****ing bitch
Simon:
The cover is definitely fierce but not the best from her and we´re talking about BEYONCÉ
Nicole:
Very very good! I think the few bits I must nit-pick at though. One that I have told a few people about is the font. Not a huge fan and the pose looks just a tad awkward for me. Nevertheless, the outfit is good (not the best). Everything else is pretty perfect; alligators on chains, the scenery. Good job.
Miley:
You REALLY need to start talking with me because this definitely would not have been my first choice. Beyoncé herself looks fierce, but the entire background around her doesn't make sense. The song is called "Ring the Alarm" so what does a swamp and alligators have to do with a scorned woman
I would have sent in the Diva cover if I were you
Madonna:
She looks awkward (I think it's the pose?) but It's a good entry.
Sky:
It's cool. The fonts bother me too much though. The editing is pretty bad too.
Christina Aguilera
Cheryl:
The problem is, we had another contestant with the Circus theme and she did it way better
Simon:
Nothing special even this one would be a better choice:
Nicole:
I think as a concept, it deserves a high mark because it’s pretty good, but then the question is, how fierce and amazing is it….still good just not incredible, so fairly decent seven.
Miley:
The more I think about it, the more I think we should have gone the Ain't No Other Man cover. This cover is fierce too and she looks elegant here and what not, but I feel like ANON would have been even more fierce with the headphones and the music in her ears and what not. You did good this round but I definitely think we could've aced this if I had said this sooner.
Madonna:
I like it... but she looks.... sad(?)
Sky:
Unremarkable in every way. But it's pretty for the most part. That border though, it's straight cut out with a "fun" pair of scissors that does quirky edges.
Team Nicole
Britney Spears
Cheryl:
PERFECT
Simon:
Perfect! This one really stands out
Nicole:
It’s not perfect, but it’s actually very good and one of the best of hers that we agreed on. I think if the font was different, a clear ten as the pose, the sparks and the dress just is so fierce. It’s a shame the font stopped it, for me, from getting perfect marks.
Miley:
As with Madonna, I just feel a bit of a disconnect with this cover. Her pose is fierce, but everything else just doesn't look right. That dress looks like an ugly nightgown and it clashes with the lighting of the sparks behind her. Her face looks very ingenuine as well. Not the worst of the round though
Madonna:
The font is ugly but she looks amazing + I love the fire(?) in the background
Sky:
I.. I strongly connect BritBrit with TERRIBLE covers. Just pure awful ****. But this is nice. The best circus/carnival/whatever themed cover in this bunch.
Shakira
Cheryl:
I can't find a flaw.
Simon:
Fierce and one of her best
Nicole:
You are scaring me. Getting two tens now is scary because I’m just waiting for when I can’t give you a ten or when you slip up. Love, love, love the concept of her in a cage, and a sexy cage might I add. Perfect skin-tight bodysuit, the black belt, her hair, the colour…I could just go on and on and pick no faults. Simply flaw free.
Miley:
All I can say is that this is PERFECT. Perfect pose, perfect background to match the song. Shakira did everything right. Keep it up Pedro!
Madonna:
Probably the best entry this round. Colombian Queen.
Sky:
The third carnival themed cover in a row. Unfortunately this is the weakest one. So instagrammed filtered. It looks like a bad fan made cover. Everything about it feels fake and like a cheap manip.
Team Madonna
Gwen Stefani
Cheryl:
This is Gwen y’all, her fashion is weird, kawaii and she rocks it.
Simon:
I don't like that black&white mixed with the horrible blue, with the horrible font, the wierd chair and that confusing outfit
Nicole:
I can see why people are not going to like this….but I really do! It’s quite “different” fierce. Really like it despite being slightly weird with that white background. I think she slays on the throne so well done.
Miley:
Gwen looks dead in this It's like she took too many sleeping pills and decided to spread her legs one more time after having wild wild sex. That's how messy this is. It's not fierce at all. It's just drab and boring.
Madonna:
I love it... It's not like you have a lot to choose from.
Sky:
Boring. The pose isn't even interesting. It's like she just got done eating and she's full or she has a hungover. There's not much going on and that isn't enough to carry this. Her fonts too, and that border, and the things in the corners, and the insignia, it's all just bad.
Jennifer Lopez
Cheryl:
Slay Michael. Glamorizing the hood
Simon:
Really?...
Nicole:
Biggest change for me from the last round. Gave you a ten last round and this round I just think you’ve totally missed it. If I had to sum it up in one word it has to be, Tacky! I’m super sorry.
Miley:
She kinda looks fierce here, but that hairstyle looks like ****, the font is terrible and amateur and she just looks like one of those bitchy soccer moms you see trying to stay young by desperately going to the salon every week to stay good-looking
Madonna:
I think the 'Dance Again' cover was better but this works.
Sky:
It's nice. I would believe it as part of a photo shoot for Vanity Fair or an obscure Vogue (not any of the major ones.) Maybe like, India. It's a BIT boring though, lbr.
Lady Gaga
Cheryl:
Even Judas can be better than Just Dance
Simon:
It's not her best but one of the most iconic from her
Nicole:
I like the retro fierceness, and the Bowie feel of it. My only problem is that’s where it stops. It doesn’t scream anything else. The pose, trying to be fierce but isn’t really. Bit disappointed you didn’t send MTN cover.
Miley:
This is the closest GaGa will ever come to looking fierce in a single cover, but this still isn't enough. Her look is great, but she is just boring as hell in this. You could've at least gone with Paparazzi
Madonna:
I love her pose. Definitely one of her best single covers.
Sky:
Sis, so many better covers. And of the TFM era ones (besides the Telephone cover with Beyonce) would have been a 10/10, even BTW would have been that. Still nice though. Just could have been better.
Team Sky
Miley Cyrus
Cheryl:
I like it but I hate it, is very Instagram
Simon:
It's cute but again.. It's not her best
Nicole:
Straight up another five. It felt in the same league of Taylor’s cover, again her lipstick being my favourite bit. It just seems so bland for what is meant to be a fierce cover. Although prettier than Taylor’s and JLO’s so I gave it a little bit higher on that regards. Who doesn’t like roses?
Miley:
There's no excuse to send THIS in when the Wrecking Ball cover was available. THAT is fierce, THIS is not. You also should have done your homework. Anything related to Adore You in this section flops, and I would know from experience. WB hands down is Miley's best single cover and THAT is what you should have sent this round.
Madonna:
I really like this cover... It's intriguing.
Sky:
A strong image. Simple to the point and fits the song, good job.
Katy Perry
Cheryl:
E.T. is better!
Simon:
It's different but i would never imagine that the title would be "Dark Horse"
Nicole:
I don’t know why I don’t like it as it’s just really unconvincing. I think unfortunately, this properly isn’t your round. I’m not just saying that. The magazine cover rounds e.t.c I know you’ll slay hard. But Katy just has really bland, almost lifeless single covers. I think California Girls and Unconditionally might have got a better score from me, but despite that, it’s not ten for any of them. Good effort though picking one of her better ones.
Miley:
The fact that is really nothing more than a drawing of Katy pretty much makes me feel totally disconnected from the cover. If there was actual presence of Katy on here, it would have turned out better.
Not the worst, but not the best.
Madonna:
Yup. Like someone (I think it was MLD?) mentioned in the thread, You are just sabotaging her on purpose.
Sky:
It's a cute illustration. An interesting choice, but there were better options out there for you.
Kylie Minogue
Cheryl:
The BEST one.
Simon:
I kind like it but I feel I could do "the same in paint"
Nicole:
I think this is simplicity at its finest. Fierce and understated. Nothing too try hard about it. Fierce pose, body, great outfit against a good backdrop and for once, the font actually works with the concept. Top job, well done!
Miley:
The pose is fierce, but the outfit makes her look like some boring 1990s blonde model wannabe and she also would blend in too easily with other people so it really defeats the purpose of this cover.
The third carnival themed cover in a row. Unfortunately this is the weakest one. So instagrammed filtered. It looks like a bad fan made cover. Everything about it feels fake and like a cheap manip.
LOL?? Someone is bitter. That's really unfair but anyway. Even with a hater I managed to get 40 Points!
LOL?? Someone is bitter. That's really unfair but anyway. Even with a hater I managed to get 40 Points!
As for the other judges, thank you so much!!
Last round:
Quote:
Sky:
I had no idea the NBA had music performances, let alone ones this grand.
And an 8/10, which 3 judges gave you. I'm not bitter over anything. My life is art/graphic design, I was harsh because I critiqued everything as I would in class.
And an 8/10, which 3 judges gave you. I'm not bitter over anything. My life is art/graphic design, I was harsh because I critiqued everything as I would in class.
Cool Beans. Now take 'word meaning' class and tell me how that cover isn't fierce.
But anyway, I am not that mad since I did good but whatever, I didn't deserve a negative number.
Iconic look btw 
You are doing well in this competition!
Um. 
but at least the cover is related to the title
It's like she took too many sleeping pills and decided to spread her legs one more time after having wild wild sex. That's how messy this is. It's not fierce at all. It's just drab and boring. 
Elimination
good luck all
My life is art/graphic design, I was harsh because I critiqued everything as I would in class.