[Truth Teller]

Originally posted by Pecinta Mariah

Last Night A DJ Saved My Life is my jam
I'd give 10 if only the song was shorter

Uhm, preach a bit The outro is cute but unecessary.

It's still not anywhere above an 8 even without the outro though

[Reverie]

Originally posted by Truth Teller

I think they wanted to evenly spread the ballads and the uptempos in the tracklist. Still, Someday would be a much better track #2

Originally posted by feelslikeadream

Prisoner deserves your 10

And YES, I always think that TGTBAW is so strangely placed. As that girl just said, Someday should have been track #2. (Btw, TGTBAW is the only debut track I don't use.)

I must confess that I found Someday to be among the tracks that didn't really move me when I listened to debut last night. Probably because I listened to it much more often than the other songs.


I have Prisoner at 9 now but will probably bump it up to a 9.5 or 10 when I'm completely done!

And I never cared for the album version of TGTBAW but I really felt it when I listened to it somehow. I think I allowed myself to believe in the song by imagining Mariah channeling all her bad memories of her childhood into the song, even if the song itself will never really be believable.

[Reverie]

Originally posted by Pecinta Mariah

Last Night A DJ Saved My Life is my jam
I'd give 10 if only the song was shorter

Originally posted by Truth Teller

Uhm, preach a bit The outro is cute but unecessary.

It's still not anywhere above an 8 even without the outro though

This rate might be the first time I listen to that song in full

[Rocket]

Originally posted by Pecinta Mariah

Loverboy is her worst lead single to date

You tried it.

[Rocket]

Through The Rain is her WORST lead single to date.

[Reverie]

I forgot that I should be going along Tigre's discussion thread and reading all the articles from each album/era! Though I'm trying to not let your opinions affect me.

[Reverie]

ALSO BEBEMINT THIS ****ED ME UP

Honestly the debut will always make me cackle because it has All In Your Mind and the beginning of that song sounds like Mariah is trapped inside of Tommy's attic and is trying to get help

[EJQL8]

I know all of them, so rates, SENT!

My 10s (and an 11):
Vision Of Love
Vanishing
Sent From Up Above
Can't Let Go
Till The End Of Time
The Wind
Music Box
Underneath The Stars
Always Be My Baby
Melt Away
Looking In
The Roof
Fourth Of July
Bliss
Crybaby
Didn't Mean To Turn You On
All My Life
You Had Your Chance
Subtle Invitation
Bringin' On The Heartbreak
It's Like That
Cruise Control
OOC
Languishing
Faded
Dedicated
Make It Look Good
You Don't Know What To Do
Meteorite

My 0s:
Hero
Just To Hold You Once Again
All I've Ever Wanted
One Sweet Day
Open Arms
When I Saw You
Against All Odds
Thank God I Found You
You Got Me
Irresistible
To The Floor
Joy Ride
Last Kiss
Bye Bye
Me. I Am Mariah... The Elusive Chanteuse
When You Believe

[Tigre]

Anyone's opinions of songs drastically change because of this rate?

I found myself getting LIFE to Till The End of Time.

Also Emotions was NOT as good as MC, even though I've always had Emotions ranked higher.

And all the songs on Music Box are fantastic, but as an album it doesn't work.

[LadyDiana]

Originally posted by Tigre

Anyone's opinions of songs drastically change because of this rate?

Same here, like now i find myself skipping hero or some other classic and jamming to underneath the stars or some other non single

Originally posted by Tigre

I found myself getting LIFE to Till The End of Time.

oh sis yaaaassss

Originally posted by Tigre

Also Emotions was NOT as good as MC, even though I've always had Emotions ranked higher.

same here, i always prefered Emotions, but I can't deny that MC is way better as whole album, like every song is perfect or almost perfect

Originally posted by Tigre

And all the songs on Music Box are fantastic, but as an album it doesn't work.

now sis thats a reach

[Mariah4life]

Originally posted by Tigre

Anyone's opinions of songs drastically change because of this rate?

I found myself getting LIFE to Till The End of Time.

Also Emotions was NOT as good as MC, even though I've always had Emotions ranked higher.

And all the songs on Music Box are fantastic, but as an album it doesn't work.

x2


Fk the music box haters. it's her top 2 best albums.

[LadyDiana]

Originally posted by Mariah4life

x2


Fk the music box haters. it's her top 2 best albums.

Now that I know

Just to hold you once again

I've been thinking about you

All I ever wanted


and those are only the worst

[OpenBacardi]

Originally posted by LadyDiana

Now that I know

Just to hold you once again

I've been thinking about you

All I ever wanted


and those are only the worst

[conatus]

Not people trying to defend Litter Box.

[conatus]

If Hell was an album.

[Subomie]

...it would be better than Charmbracelet.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Subomie

...it would be better than Charmbracelet.

You tried it.

[Altidor]

Wow, this discography rate has made me go back and get my LIFE from a couple of gems.

I started yesterday and I'm on Butterfly and woo LAWD, I don't think I ever heard the solo version of Whenever You Call before and I think I was delieverdT all over again!

[feelslikeadream]

Originally posted by Altidor

Wow, this discography rate has made me go back and get my LIFE from a couple of gems.

I started yesterday and I'm on Butterfly and woo LAWD, I don't think I ever heard the solo version of Whenever You Call before and I think I was delieverdT all over again!

That's one purpose of the rate; now y'all can stop sleeping on great album tracks (like Alone In Love)

[Ash12345]

I decided to join the club
I've always been a casual fan of the queen of everything, but ive never really listened to more than just the singles, so im gonna like try and listen to a mariah carey album every day now haha
I listened to the debut today and wowow at prisoner, vision of love, love takes time
its so so good