[castle13]

Song: 7
Video: 7
Cover: 7

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Song: 10
Video: 9.5
Cover: 8

[potent]

Song: 4
Video: 8
Cover: 5

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by madonnas

Song: 1/10
Video: 5.5/10
Cover: 8/10

Interesting.

[Niksan555]

Song: 7/10
Video: 0/10
Cover: 7/10

[Beautiful Sinner]

Song: 8/10
Video: 10/10
Cover: 9/10

[allm1314]

song: 7.5/10
video: 4/10
cover: 7/10

[umich]

Song: 5/10
Video: 6/10
Cover: 2/10

[Capital B]

Song: 1/10
Video: 1/10
Cover: 7/10

[Dickard]

Song: 8/10
Video: 6/10 (the copyright lawsuit really turned me off)
Cover: 7/10

[Lucas32]

Song: 10 for Rihannas part / 2 for Britneys(her voice) makes a 6 together
Video: 9
Cover: 6
The original is much better

[ifyouseekLEM]

Song: 5/10
Video: 8/10
Cover: 7/10

[OnlyRihanna]

Song : 9
Video : 10
Cover: 9

[Sinister]

I only like the original but I have to rate the awful remix

Song:4/10
Cover: 7?/10
Video: 10/10 (good thing there was no remix vid)

[Ady.]

song: 10/10
video: 7/10
cover: 7/10

Big fan of this song.

[alkralkra]

1
6
3

[Rominho.]

Song: 3 (Original >>>>>>>)
Video: 9
Cover: 9

[cuitrex]

Song: 8

Video: 9

Cover :8.8

[Navyboy20]

I dont understand. S&M was already sitting nice and pretty at #2 before the remix was released. Yes it boosted it to #1 but w/o the original song & video it would have never even made it to the top 5.

That being said I will rate the REMIX like you asked me.

Song: 4/10
Video: N/A (The remix had no video)
Cover: 3/10

That hurt

But as for the original

Song: 9/10
Video: 10/10
Cover: 7/10

[Smooth Criminal]

The original is cool. The remix they made in a hurry and didn't get any airplay is crap.