Quote:
Originally posted by Isou-44
Since SG and CRTGY are probably going to be released during the same week, it's fine to say the snippet of the latter sounds really bad, basic, and outdated, not a comeback single at all and it's already getting bad reviews.
SG snippets have been getting nothing but good reviews and they all sound way better.
|
Neither of these songs have gotten real reviews and any reviews you're referring to are either b/s stan critiques that mean nothing or rushed first impressions.
In terms of what fares better critically, we'll have to wait until both are officially released. But judging from the snippets imo neither sound like a total trainwreck. I actually prefer Shakira's to JLo's snippets tbh, I think her song sounds a little fresher. Jen's new song kind of sounds like hip-pop filler but we'll see. Still waaaaaay better than Live It Up thats for sure.
Out of the two Shakira definitely has the upper hand in terms of who will probably get the most radio support since she has Rihanna on her track, otherwise Jennifer would've been the shoe-in because of Idol. But the thing the two of these women have in common is that neither of them could end up getting any radio support because both of them have been pretty inconsistent on American radio. Very inconsistent actually.