oh thanks for shutting the discussion down, wonder what would the industry do without your opinion
Quote:
Originally posted by hEz_iRvy_iRv
man you stay trying
it cudn't get clearer
She's praised for her range every farking time yet she's nowhere near the likes of Mariah Carey.
Those high notes are always strained like nail scratchin on a chalkboard and carry no emotion, they all sound the same. She's never comfortable, it seems painful even. Not sayin her range isn't impressive, she doesn't have much control over it though.
Pink sounds like she gargles rocks and tar every night before bed.
Christina is guilty of over-singing just about anything she gets her hands on, and while it's impressive to some, it really just illustrates her lack of control and is reminiscent of that girl with "the voice" who went to your high school. You remember her? She thought she was God's gift to music and the easily impressed hailed her as a star in the making. She participated in (and won) every talent show, shouting (or, belted as defenders of this style will try to label it) her way straight to mediocrity. Since graduation she has started a lucrative career waiting tables at Denny's, but never one to give up on her dream, she's also a struggling songwriter/video vixen with "connections" to some one-hit-wonders and irrelevant producers.
And just for a heads up, you can skip the "How is the dude who stans for Rihanna and Britney going to come for Christina or Pink's vocals!?" comments.
Eh No, Beyonce probably could shine with Shakira but Christina is another level only Whitney or Celine probably can make the competition with her. Pink is a great vocalist but she has her way and her type of voice is more to the rock genre than pop.
Shakira.
Beyonce would ****ing slaughter all of them are you serious?
and Xtina's head notes are better than Beyonce's, plus her belting notes are more thicker and louder and Xtina has a better lower register.. But Bey has the better tone and control.
People understand that Christina is The voice of our generation so stop trying
P!nk and Beyonce are amazing too but nowhere near to Christina
Lesser girls gotta hold on to the range cos they got nothing else. It's a gift people, you could extend it only by a few notes, it's all about how you use your potential and unlike many of you fail to see sometimes less is more