lol at how mad you're getting. Just take a chill pill already. I was only contributing to the discussion because someone else pointed out how Pink comes off as outspoken while Xtina comes off as conceited. Performing a charity concert is not really indicative of anything, but I didn't say Xtina didn't give a **** about stuff. It's just that she's way more famous for saying really low, personal stuff about her peers, and does that with a much greater frequency than Pink does, so it contributes to her being seen as arrogant. Pink can hate too, but she always draws a line. Xtina doesn't.
Nah - Pink is just as guilty about throwing shade at other pop stars. Quite possibly more than Christina, tbh.
My theory to the op's original question, however, is that while Pink is more commercially successful, Christina is still, by far, more talked about.
One example of this is TIME magazine's 2014 list of most-obsessed about celebrities on the web:
1. George Bush
2. Barack Obama
3. Madonna
4. Beyonce
12. Christina Aguilera
85. Pink
So while both Xtina/Pink shade other pop stars, and both contribute to charity, people are just more inclined to talk about Christina thank Pink. That's even evident on ATRL...
P!nk's attitude and whole persona in general is reminiscent of a typical guy (I'm not shading her, but she's a huge tomboy lbr) So when she's honest or cracks a joke, it's fine.
Christina on the other hand is very feminine, so when she's honest it comes across as catty and bitchy.
P!nk's a just there type of artist that people don't even want to put effort in giving her something as personal as emotion with her attitude. Hate's a way greater emotion than love, and takes way more effort to make, and/or give out, so either way X wins in the public's eye, and she stays more relevant to them than P!nk.
"Just there" is always better than "It's almost like she wasn't even there." Kimmel on Christina
Pink's anything but truly outspoken. She's a intimidated, scared, and lost girl. Xtina's regal, and overpowering nature left Pink soft spoken, and stuttering when they were on the radio together with Ryan. That's power.
Well that's just not true at all, and you know it.
Nobody cares about issues SHE'S going through, I mean ISSUES. Real stuff. Not things that are all about me, me, me. No one gives a damn about some rich bitch being sad.
Hmmm they cared about her divorce, weight gain, superbowl flub (still waiting for Pink to perform tbh ) grammy fall, arrest, etc..m hell.. even more than Pink's whole pregnancy and birth, even pregnancy!
P!nk's attitude and whole persona in general is reminiscent of a typical guy (I'm not shading her, but she's a huge tomboy lbr) So when she's honest or cracks a joke, it's fine.
Christina on the other hand is very feminine, so when she's honest it comes across as catty and bitchy.
lol at how mad you're getting. Just take a chill pill already. I was only contributing to the discussion because someone else pointed out how Pink comes off as outspoken while Xtina comes off as conceited. Performing a charity concert is not really indicative of anything, but I didn't say Xtina didn't give a **** about stuff. It's just that she's way more famous for saying really low, personal stuff about her peers, and does that with a much greater frequency than Pink does, so it contributes to her being seen as arrogant. Pink can hate too, but she always draws a line. Xtina doesn't.
She has done a lot more than just perform at charity concerts
Christina doesn't choose what the media chooses to focus on, her doing charity work will never be as big a headline to them as her saying something bitchy. Negativity sells, why do you think you get more headlines about celebs failing relationships than successful ones? Not because there are more unsuccessful ones, but because media don't care about positive aspects of celebrities and their lives as much as they do the drama filled negatives.
Hmmm they cared about her divorce, weight gain, superbowl flub (still waiting for Pink to perform tbh ) grammy fall, arrest, etc..m hell.. even more than Pink's whole pregnancy and birth, even pregnancy!
Making fun of her does not mean they care about her. What kind of sad relationships have you established in your life???
She has done a lot more than just perform at charity concerts
Christina doesn't choose what the media chooses to focus on, her doing charity work will never be as big a headline to them as her saying something bitchy. Negativity sells, why do you think you get more headlines about celebs failing relationships than successful ones? Not because there are more unsuccessful ones, but because media don't care about positive aspects of celebrities and their lives as much as they do the drama filled negatives.
The media wouldn't have any of that negativity to focus on if she didn't put the negativity out there herself. Her image now is a result of her own consequences.
Hmmm they cared about her divorce, weight gain, superbowl flub (still waiting for Pink to perform tbh ) grammy fall, arrest, etc..m hell.. even more than Pink's whole pregnancy and birth, even pregnancy!
Except that Xtina has never been the superbowl halftime headliner.
The time that she "performed" was not even her own song, and she flubbed the lyrics...
So call me when Xtina performs her halftime show when Pink has more of a chance than she does.
Hmmm they cared about her divorce, weight gain, superbowl flub (still waiting for Pink to perform tbh ) grammy fall, arrest, etc..m hell.. even more than Pink's whole pregnancy and birth, even pregnancy!
Not you thinking that these negative news are anything to shout about. You need help.
Cause P!nk confronts every negative press and things she doesn't like in her environment. It's all her honesty that makes her a likeable person.
Whereas Christina has carried on her diva attitude through all these years and either is too shy talking about issues or reveals superficial details and only half the story.
If this same topic were changed to Lady GaGa...Katy Perry it would have been closed before the first page was filled. Is there a mod that also happens to be a Fighter?
Pink's anything but truly outspoken. She's a intimidated, scared, and lost girl. Xtina's regal, and overpowering nature left Pink soft spoken, and stuttering when they were on the radio together with Ryan. That's power.
She rather sounded calm and unbothered by the whole thing which was obviously a way to stir things up between them again. Christina was on the edge of being a bitch, especially with the "hahaha no" comment on the playdates. P!nk kept it classy at least and always moved the conversation from them to other topics to avoid the any drama.
I think Christina is very misunderstood. Sure, she had some really shady moments back in the day, but that was back when she was being attacked by the media right, left and center. She was defensive, not bitchy. She hasn't been shady since 2008, with the "man or a woman" thing. On The Voice, she was simply opinionated and she spoke truth. Sure, she could have been more polite, but there are tons of other judges that have said way worse and got away with it. People just love to hate Christina.