[BubbleGomme]

Stay was bigger in terms of peak and success.

[iamanearthling]

stay and its not even close.

[lonnie]

Originally posted by Haribo

Stay smashed at the beginning of 2013, not in November. And even if it wasn't the peak, 2013's digital sales were bigger than 2009's.

None of the singles from 2013 outsold the likes of I've got a feeling. Poker face, Just dance even single ladies from the year before did very well singles wise, in fact singles were selling more in 09 than in 2013.

[TeemoR]

Halo DUH what an insult

[BeyonceHatesMe]

Originally posted by RickyH.

Stay. Halo is SO overrated on this forum. Both in terms of quality and success

[Slayonce]

Halo is a classic so I'm gonna go with it.

[lonnie]

Originally posted by Slayonce

Halo is a classic so I'm gonna go with it.

In what world is halo a classic? I mean I LOVE the song but it is hardly a classic.

[Mileymore]

Halo

[OffTheWall]

Both were big but Halo felt much bigger

[MM3]

Halo was bigger.

[Jabril]

Halo by far

[Timber]

Halo is almost at 9M sold. I think Stay has outsold it in the U.S. but not WW.

[Repo]

Halo. It was so big that Kelly Clarkson reused the production on a single:

[Lucyyyyyyyyy]

Stay

[Desert Rain]

Halo sold more.
Halo is more acclaimed.
Halo is more remembered.

[22 Two's]

Originally posted by lonnie

It did not.

8.8 million copies. ha longevity >>>>>

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=323424

Originally posted by Haribo

This. Stay was released at the peak of the digital era.

Originally posted by Lxdy Gaga

Didn't Halo sell 9M+ WW?

EDIT: Voted Halo because it's the better song

Originally posted by Rafael

The only clear answer here is Halo.

Yall do too much on Stay... it's basically Rihanna trying to be Adele... and both of them were big hits so I'll take the Grammy awarded one

Originally posted by Desert Rain

Halo sold more.
Halo is more acclaimed.
Halo is more remembered.

[Kworb]

Stay was bigger commercially, but Halo was and is covered a lot more especially on talent shows.

[Teen Idle]

Halo is remembered

[Shady]

Stay, it's also the better song.

[lonnie]

Originally posted by 22 Two's

8.8 million copies. ha longevity >>>>>

http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=323424

The INFLATION
halo did not sell that much
It never even passee the 4M mark in the U.S