[DitaBoy12]

Originally posted by madonnas

Don't be a hater! Her self titled is her most influential album along with ROL and LAP.

Not a hater and I respect your opinion but Erotica >>>>>

[minho]

Hard Candy as a whole, but COADF songs like Forbidden Love, Isaac & How High are even better than the ones on HC.

I'd say they're even but I'll go with Hard Candy.

[Quiqui4eva]

Confessions by LIGHT YEARS. How can people vote otherwise?

[Swag]

COADF.

[minho]

Originally posted by madonnas

It's about even but HC.

Let it Will Be, Jump, and Push are worse than anything on HC but other than those songs the average song on COADF > the average song on HC.

What. I love this song! The others I agree with though.

[SailorMoon]

Originally posted by lousaysthings

Stuart Price did such an amazing job on COADF that I have to go for that.

+1
the production was absolutely flawless minus a couple of songs, but even the bad ones (Isaac) were still good.

While Hard Candy we were stuck with listening to overdrawn songs that didn't flow well and when it was bad...it was bad (i.e. Spanish Lesson, Dance 2Night,)

[Legacy]

I hate both tbh. I'd say COADF though because it was huge, the production is better and Hung Up is still a bop as well as Sorry.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by DitaBoy12

Not a hater and I respect your opinion but Erotica >>>>>

Erotica and Music are her best albums but they're not her most essential

[DitaBoy12]

Originally posted by madonnas

Erotica and Music are her best albums but they're not her most essential

So according to you the only reason "madonna" is essential is because it was her first album?

[Blueberry Mary]

It's difficult, but I have to on Confessions, purely based on production.

[Reinvention]

Ugh I just listened to "Miles Away" and remembered that, that song is literally one of Madonna's best.

[Lucita]

Confessions by miles.

[LoveLiveMusic]

Confessions will always come out on top, but I love so many tracks on Hard Candy

[LeooAyala]

COADF, but Hard Candy is really good too

[Kyle-x]

Confessions in every single way.

[Ezekiel]

Confessions!

Edit: Hard Candy slays so idk

[Lord Gaga]

Not sure if you people who say hard candy are trolling or not. Hung up alone >>>>>>>>>

[deepblue]

COADF
Get together>>>>

[Beyondslay]

Confessions remains superior...she still has never topped it.

[abrahamjmr]

Even thought I don't like Madonna, Confessions is better than Hard Candy by a large margin.