[Alvajay]

Originally posted by Rolland

She is just a pop-star, selling ultra-commercial music labeling it as "art" when it has nothing of artistic. There will always be stupid people that will believe anything so...

perfectly said

[Scandal & Media]

Why does Gaga have you so bothered lately? Didn't you have her in your signature not too long ago?

[Retro]

She is both an artist and a pop star; the two are not mutually exclusive.

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by Evans

one second she's a koons, suddenly the koons is her

[vanishingbee]

she breaks the barrier between the two and is both, of course!

[Scandal & Media]

But anyway, that aside, she is both. A pop artist. Does atrl even know what "artist" means?

[Pixel]

Both

[zach]

Both.

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by Rolland

She is just a pop-star, selling ultra-commercial music labeling it as "art" when it has nothing of artistic. There will always be stupid people that will believe anything so...

Lets just get some definitions out so that we can based on FACTS and not your lonely opinion.

art
noun
1.
the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form such as painting or sculpture, producing works to be appreciated primarily for their beauty or emotional power.

works produced by human creative skill and imagination. EXAMPLE, WRITING

and being that she takes part in the writing of the music, this is her expression. So before you call anyone out for being stupid, maybe you should take into account the definition of art, but then again art is subjective, it may NOT be art to you, but you won't be able to say what does what and what effect it has on other people. So, speak for yourself and don't put other people don't for voicing their opinion.

[Beatfreak]

Originally posted by ethaniel

She's got a schtick just like all the other pop girls. She's a pop star.



ARTPOP It's all over ATRL...

I think they were being rhetorical.

[MJ Boston]

She is probably the most classic definition of a pop star. More so than all the other gorls. I wouldn't say she isn't an artist, I just feel that real artists don't have to try so hard to throw that in your face.

[BBathHausOfGaga]

Both

[gagakyle]

So many people have their own limited definitions of art in this thread for some reason

[Dani97]

Originally posted by Scandal & Media

But anyway, that aside, she is both. A pop artist. Does atrl even know what "artist" means?

This is ATRL, "artist" or "musician" have a whole different meaning, you just have to sing on key and dance to be called a true talent, true musician.

[seanoh]

She's a popstar that makes basic dance music like every other pop girl, but the difference is that she labels it as art.

[DitaBoy12]

she is just a pop star.

[Arking]

Both?

She's a musical/visual/performance artist that's been elevated to pop star status through her work.

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by Arking

Both?

She's a musical/visual/performance artist that's been elevated to pop star status through her work.

I agree.


They're ALL called recording artists for a reason, what they release is art, not only Gaga but all the artists out there. Their art is MUSIC.

basic people = basic minds.

[Scandal & Media]

Originally posted by TREMendo

I agree.


They're ALL called recording artists for a reason, what they release is art, not only Gaga but all the artists out there. Their art is MUSIC.

basic people = basic minds.

!!!

[Grumpy Gills]

Just because we ain't deep don't mean we can't enjoy the shallow