Quote:
Originally posted by swissman
The growling is stylistic not a sign of deteriorating vocal ranges, especially when she's doing more than what she did before when she did softer vocals.
------------------------------------
On 4 she let her vocals be raw and capture that live aspect instead of giving perfectly polished vocals.
|
I really hate growls, it's something so acclaimed by the vocals profanes and by the likers of loud singers and perceived as proof of emotion. I really hate them. Whitney was called too "perfect", too "white" and too "pop", emotionless at her peak because she was not that into that. Mariah Carey had no soul and was emotionless for the same reason. It's just stupid and lacks esthetic imo.
------------------
It was maybe rawer but I don't think she really captured the raw aspect of her live performances. 11 is miles better live than in studio, I think at one point she was just pushing her vocals too hard wanting it to match the live experience;