Quote:
Originally posted by ZachM
okay...you just called their music generic. i don't like generic music. i wrote that like a year ago when i first joined and didn't feel like finishing it. I don't have a "favorite," i like everyone. And everyone isn't generic, so that point is irrelevant, and I can "pass judgement" if I want, thanks. My point is that it's generic. if you've listened to one song from them you've listened to them all. i didn't mean to sound condescending, i apologize. There's nothing wrong with a good ol' generic fun pop dance song, heck as you so kindly pointed out, some of the artists i enjoy listening to produce some. But it's bad when that's ALL you're producing.
but i still stick to what i said. generic. boring. major yawn. call me when they have something great.
|
Agree with this a lot. 1D is not known for being groundbreaking. While I do think this song is actually one of the more refreshing ones they've released, melodically and hook-wise, it's still basically in the vein of all of their other songs. That my not be a bad thing, but it's not like people listen to 1D because they are making exciting pop music or anything. Unfortunately, I feel the same way about them as I do about some other artists that people go nuts for here; they can make some great, catchy tracks, but a lot of these tend to lose their appeal in a matter of a few days of playing them, and that's kind of it. And really, I tend to pull out my stan card for acts that can at least get to the point of being able to offer more, so in that sense I do understand what you mentioned earlier. However, I'm prob a bit older than a lot of the 1D fans here who "get" this more these days, so to each their own of course. Everyone has their own NSYNC/BSB/Britney/Miley/etc.