[Dr. Shenanigans]

Originally posted by madonnas

Beyoncé is more consistent, but Gaga has higher highs.

This basically.

A Beyonce performance is always well done, fantastics vocals, decent choreography, but her performances also end up feeling the same and don't feel as special and lose a lot of charm.

Gaga can put out fantastic performances and has moments where everything just all comes together, voice, choreo, and theatrics, like Paparazzi at the VMAs, that put Beyonce to shame. However she also has a lot of mediocre to bad ones where the the entire theme just feels overthought.

I vote Beyonce just because of her consistency but Gaga is far more interesting imo, she just isn't at her absolute best enough for her to win this imo.

[Bey'Knight]

Originally posted by Somalian Hooker

Irrelevant. People like theatrics obviously.

They do the first 10 times u do it, after it gets stale. Even Pink is now getting flack for her acrobatics so is Chris Brown but at least thats them actually doing something physically

[Vanitas]

Originally posted by Bey'Knight

Actually what was Gaga's last memorable performance? I honestly dont rmbr. The theatrics arent shocking or spectacular anymore. They seem more like a distraction tactic now.

This coming from a Beyonce fan.

[Amaru]

You will never be disappointed at a Beyonce concert.

But you haven't lived until you've seen Stefani live.

[Somalian Hooker]

Originally posted by abdielol

"Gimmicks" are part of the theatrics. And since theatrics are PART of a performance, I think we all agree on who's the better performer.

We'll have to tell them again, they don't seem to get it.

[Kool_Aid_King]

Originally posted by Somalian Hooker

Did you just try and justify Rihanna's poor touring performance to her RACE?

It totally has nothing to do with her awful performance and vocal reputation in touring.


Not flaming, just being honest. People go to Gaga because she puts on a good show and can sing. They don't go to rihanna because Rih can't do that.

It is due to her race. People go to tours to listen to the music. Her voice is decent, and she puts on an adequate show.

Her albums sell really well in EU so people would go regardless.

[Katamari]

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

-Post 2003. There are 2 or 3 performances of the King doing below average performances

what are they

[Bey'Knight]

Originally posted by HausOfJabril

Can I ask you what was Beyonce's last "memorable" performance?

Glastonbury OR BMA. Take your pick.

[Damien M]

Originally posted by madonnas

Beyoncé is more consistent, but Gaga has higher highs.

Right.
This is the only logical answer, really.

[Glam]

Beyonce but she's also had more time performing than Gaga.

[Callisto.]

Originally posted by Katamari

what are they

To show them would embarrass other pop stars
Being that Beyonces worst is still miles better than their best.

[Jabril]

Originally posted by Bey'Knight

Glastonbury OR BMA. Take your pick.

Glastonbury?
No one remembers that but the BeyHive.
The BMA performance was nice and might be remembered for another year and a half, maybe.

[Bey'Knight]

Originally posted by abdielol

This coming from a Beyonce fan.

How many times did Gaga perform marry the night exclusively? What impact was made?

Bey's last televised performance ie A night with Beyonce shook up the UK charts and that was just on itv.

[Jabril]

Originally posted by Bey'Knight

How many times did Gaga perform marry the night exclusively? What impact was made?

Bey's last televised performance ie A night with Beyonce shook up the UK charts and that was just on itv.

"A Night With Beyonce"?

[Katamari]

Originally posted by iBeyoncé.

To show them would embarrass other pop stars
Being that Beyonces worst is still miles better than their best.

lol if they were posted we would have a clear answer tho

[liferekindled]

Originally posted by Somalian Hooker

The one who's in higher demand and is the more successful touring artist...

Honestly, Beyonce is black, so that's a factor.

[Glam]

So this is quickly eroding into a shadefest as expected.

I love how these two stanbases brag to no end (and sometimes stand together) about how they stan for the two best performers currently but whenever they are pitted against each other they conveniently forget about the other fave's memorable performances

[Bey'Knight]

Originally posted by HausOfJabril

Glastonbury?
No one remembers that but the BeyHive.
The BMA performance was nice and might be remembered for another year and a half, maybe.

Says who? Beyonce made history that night. That's not going to be forgotten soon. In a poll, the UK voted her the best performer at that event. When glasto comes back, it will be referenced again. Wasnt it only recently said that it also broke BBC ratings record? Exactly

[Tropez]

Originally posted by liferekindled

Honestly, Beyonce is black, so that's a factor.

That didn't stop Michael Jackson in the 80s.

But I could be wrong.

[Jabril]

Originally posted by liferekindled

Honestly, Beyonce is black, so that's a factor.

Why is the BeyHive pulling the race card? Are you saying she only caters to black people and doesn't have a variety in fans?