[Belle]

She's still perfectly capable of having artistic control even with those things the failed logic

[Vin]

(CNN) -- Is Lady Gaga an artist?

My influence has finally reached CNN News.
CNN creating a Vin Thread. I love it. And I agree with them.



...CNN

[MusicTalker]

Originally posted by Blueberry Kisses

Some of you are so... I'm not even going there. What Gaga does is the definition of artistry, how would sitting and performing her songs with jeans and t-shirt on be more artistic than what she does now? I don't get it.

She is an artist but some people are too vapid & instantly just call her a gimmick who wears costumes to get attention. The irony is that it doesn't overshadow her music. She's the girl who has sold like 20 million records in four years & gotten at least 10 hits. Last year she got one of the biggest ww hits of all time yet people still wanna say she's overshadowing her own music.

[thediscomonkey]

A very well written article. There's no snobbery here. It's basically what ppl feel all the time. The writer just made Joanne as the example. But this actually applies to every artist, not just her.

[SolarFlare]

Lady Gaga is a liar. She uses her brainwashed fans to promote her agenda. Like Madonna. Like any pop artist, actually. You all should stop listening to this garbagge music, and listen to indie artists instead.

[Christina-Lover]

CNN clocking the true

[jose168]

yea but her image is part of the art, saying she isnt an artist is stupid

[conseeded]

Originally posted by SolarFlare

Lady Gaga is a liar. She uses her brainwashed fans to promote her agenda. Like Madonna. Like any pop artist, actually. You all should stop listening to this garbagge music, and listen to indie artists instead.

You won't last long

They make a valid point at the end though.
Her entire image IS art though, so

[KESTER]

Originally posted by Beautiful Liar

Gaga stans lets be honest

If this article was about someone other than Lady Gaga

ya will be in here co-signing with the article

am I lying?

Depends who it's about... If it's about a label puppet then yes obviously, but Gaga isn't a label puppet. She's an artist.

[Belle]

Originally posted by SolarFlare

Lady Gaga is a liar. She uses her brainwashed fans to promote her agenda. Like Madonna. Like any pop artist, actually. You all should stop listening to this garbagge music, and listen to indie artists instead.

The hell are you doing on a pop forum?

[Boop]

Originally posted by SAFEYEAA

Depends who it's about... If it's about a label puppet then yes obviously, but Gaga isn't a label puppet. She's an artist.

Clocked.

[Evangeline]

Some of the points they've bought up are valid,it's true that image matters more than music in pop music scene now.But I don't quite agree about what they've said about Gaga.It's true that when you say 'Lady Gaga',her outfits come into most people's minds before her music or her songs do,but that's because that's what provides her most distinctive edge.Same can be said about all visual popstars,their images leave more of an impact on people's minds.That doesn't mean she's not a real musician and that there's no artistry involved in work.Eventually,if she doesn't fade in oblivion,her music will also be remembered.

[Flashing Lights]

Well, at least they're not just focusing it on the present like some people do.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Vin

My influence has finally reached CNN News.
CNN creating a Vin Thread. I love it. And I agree with them.



...CNN

So you admit Kesha's a faceless, anonymous pre-fabrication of a pop star?

[Christina-Lover]

"I don't consider Gaga an artist," the New York style consultant says, then reconsiders. "Well, maybe she's an artist for our time. Every generation gets the artist it deserves."

I can't at CNN shading this generation

[MusicTalker]

I love that these articles are written about her on her BREAK.

Who else?

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Most of you didn't read the whole thing.

[Boop]

Originally posted by Allstar

So you admit Kesha's a faceless, anonymous pre-fabrication of a pop star?

at him not reading the article and getting dragged by his own words

[slayHa]

nothing but the truth, her latest antics on twitter shows the world she is nothing but greedy for attention

[SolarFlare]

Originally posted by jose168

yea but her image is part of the art, saying she isnt an artist is stupid

She isnt an artist. Why, you ask? While she is indeed talented, she uses her talented in the wrong way -- meaning that her message and music is geared toward her agenda, and making people worship her as a God. What I'm trying to say is look at her fans. They call her "GodGa", what the hell is this? She is no God. There is only ONE God, and that is not her or any pop artist. Pop artist are just regular people who make recycled **** music for brainwashed masses. Quit listening to it, it just follows the agenda of the ELITE to make people dumb and worship dumb celebrities so that they can manipulate everyone easly.