[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by JakeKills

Let's just all be grateful that Today Was A Fairytale is conspiculously absent from this rate.

Still would have given it a seven.

[Achilles.]

Safe & Sound was only a promo single.

[CountryFriedChick]

Originally posted by Mezik

10/10 From me!

It's the only song of hers I have on my iPod besides Teardrops on My Guitar, Our Song, Love Story, You Belong With Me, Back To December, Mine, Haunted, Safe & Sound and Eyes Open.

I see well at least the rest of your Taylor songs are in good taste naw its a good song the production really bothers me alot though

[Achilles.]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Still would have given it a seven.

You are a better stan than me.

[Mezik]

Originally posted by CountryFriedChick

I see well at least the rest of your Taylor songs are in good taste naw its a good song the production really bothers me alot though

Story of Us deserved so much more..

[Jdella11]

Ya'll exposing me for missing these Taylor songs.

I updated Today Is A Fairytale and Safe and Sound. So Taylor should now have another bottom 5 and top 10 in the rate.

[Mezik]

What about Ever Ever After & There's a Place for Us for Carrie?

Actually no.. just ignore them.. just don't even remember I mentioned that.

[Jdella11]

Originally posted by Mezik

What about Ever Ever After & There's a Place for Us for Carrie?

Actually no.. just ignore them.. just don't even remember I mentioned that.

I've wiped Ever Ever After from my mind. I literally blocked it from memory. But **** it, both songs added to the list.

[thediscomonkey]

*eternal audience here* Good luck y'all. Be objective. Judge the song, ONLY.

[Mezik]

Originally posted by Jdella11

I've wiped Ever Ever After from my mind. I literally blocked it from memory. But **** it, both songs added to the list.

And Carrie is going to have two in the bottom five.. she betta get dem hitz!

[Jdella11]

Originally posted by Mikal

Do we have to rate all three ladies or can I just submit votes for Miranda? I don't listen to Carrie (residual hate since she beat Bo so many seasons ago) and I'm pretty sure I'd rate all of Taylor's songs at 0 (ok, maybe not "Our Song") due to my irrational hate of her.

edit: I did see TWAF was left off. I'd have to ask if negative ratings could be given

I'd prefer if you did them all, Taylor could use some low scores anyways. If you honestly think all Taylor songs are a 0 though, I'd be fine with just taking the Miranda scores.

[Achilles.]

Carrie
Highest: 10 (x4)
Lowest: 2 (x2)
Average: 7.4 (those two 2s really hurt her)

Taylor
Highest: 10 (x5)
Lowest: 3 (x1)
Average: 8.5

Miranda
Highest: 10 (x2)
Lowest: 3 (x1)
Average: 8

I gave a lot of Taylor's songs lower scores than I wanted to.

[castle13]

I'm so ready for this!

[@michael]

Looking at Miranda's list makes me think of all the great songs she hasn't released as singles But I'm still Team Miranda all the way

[castle13]

Taylor
Highest - 10(X5)
Lowest - 5 (x1)
Ave - 9.31

Carrie
Highest - 10 (x4)
Lowest - 6(x2)
Ave - 8.63

Miranda
Highest - 10 (x1)
Lowest - 6 (x2)
Ave - 7.59

[Jdella11]

Originally posted by @michael.

Looking at Miranda's list makes me think of all the great songs she hasn't released as singles But I'm still Team Miranda all the way

I'm counting on you. Looking at the current scores, Miranda really needs someone who will give her more than just 7's and 8's.

[castle13]

@Jdella11

Did you receive my votes?
Thanks.

[tell_me_a_lie]

I can't wait to join. I'm here to give a fair score to Carrie.

[Jdella11]

Originally posted by tell_me_a_lie

I can't wait to join. I'm here to give a fair score to Carrie.

Originally posted by castle13

@Jdella11

Did you receive my votes?
Thanks.

Got both!

[Jdella11]

Everyone dragging Mama's Song though.

It ain't right, it just ain't right.