[Starburst]

Originally posted by slayHa

Sweety battleship. Birthday cake the new black hair... She is in the media.day in day out. Gaga..not so much. Gaga have not seen the same spike in popularity since bad romance.

Did you miss the release of Born This Way? (the single and album) You sound delusional.

Originally posted by gagakyle

The one with a #1 album.

[chilicheese01]

Gaga.

Rihanna will not impress me until she changes the game a little. She released basically the same two albums within two years with a different cover and name, and they were both very similar to GGGB. Please bring something new. Maybe that's why I loved Rated R...

[Amaru]

Originally posted by gagakyle

The one with a #1 album.

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

OBVIOUSLY Gaga. Rihanna is holding steady in the runners-up spot though.

[z10]

Originally posted by slayHa

Sweety battleship. Birthday cake the new black hair... She is in the media.day in day out. Gaga..not so much. Gaga have not seen the same spike in popularity since bad romance.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by slayHa

Rihanna is a 24 year old with 11number 1 hits. The end

[okiam]

Originally posted by Evun

Really though, our generation deserves better than these two options.

[slayHa]

Originally posted by Starburst

Did you miss the release of Born This Way? (the single and album)

Yes

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

I can't really imagine the top gal not having a number one album.

[Monkey_Juice]

Originally posted by chris1991

Rihanna! Gaga may have had a HUGE spike at one point, but Princess Riri has been riding HIGH at the same level of gaga's huge spike for years now.

+ Rihanna will last longer

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by Vin

Rihanna has arguably increased her popularity with every era, while Lady Gaga
had her peak with "Bad Romance" and, unsurprisingly, continues to steadily decline.

...Vin

Definitely not. Her peak was definitely GGGB

[ifyouseekLEM]

Originally posted by Last Boy on Earth

There is always 1 #1 black girl and 1 1# white girl.. Whitney and Madonna in the 80s. Mariah and Janet in the 90s, Britney and Beyoncé in the 00s. Rihanna and Gaga now

Ill go with this answer. Though I was honestly leaning towards Rihanna.

[Clump]

Lady Gaga has the talent to transition into a more mature sound and audience as she ages. I could see her having a show in Vegas after she's done slaying the world.

[Stevie]

This thread is hilarious.

Originally posted by Swag

Beyonce

[Last Boy on Earth]

Originally posted by BoyOnBoy Wonder

I can't really imagine the top gal not having a number one album.

Tina Turner doesn't have one and she's a bigger legend than Gaga will ever be

[z10]

Originally posted by chris1991

A few underperforming singles, 11+ number #1s, We found love. Riri's just fine tbfh! But thanks for worrying though! Kiss!

Gaga has had 1 underperforming single, she was never a #1 singles artist: always Top 10, she's got her #1 albums , higher tour gross'. I mean, don't act as though Gaga isn't a force to be reckoned with.

[ifyouseekLEM]

Originally posted by Last Boy on Earth

There is always 1 #1 black girl and 1 1# white girl.. Whitney and Madonna in the 80s. Mariah and Janet in the 90s, Britney and Beyoncé in the 00s. Rihanna and Gaga now

Devil's Advocate: It's actually Rihanna and Katy Perry. Not GaGa.

[Honey]

Originally posted by Last Boy on Earth

There is always 1 #1 black girl and 1 1# white girl.. Whitney and Madonna in the 80s. Mariah and Janet in the 90s, Britney and Beyoncé in the 00s. Rihanna and Gaga now

But... Mariah is half-black and half-white.

[Stevie]

Originally posted by Clump

Lady Gaga has the talent to transition into a more mature sound and audience as she ages. I could see her having a show in Vegas after she's done slaying the world.

A show in vegas?
Not really helping your argument.

[gagakyle]

Originally posted by gagakyle

The one with a #1 album.

Reported