I think Haley did better than Gaga in both videos posted here. I never really liked Haley but she's improving a lot in the show, I actually want her, Scotty and James in the final 3.
I think Gaga's voice lacks something that Haley's voice has. Haley just sings it more passionately than Gaga does.
Those reviews were simply horrible. The three of them should be ashamed. She really sang that song. As far as no one having heard the song before- we all know it now!! I guess the message is forget your talent and music abilties and just concentrate on winning. What are the last two Idol winners doing now? Last I heard most of the previous winners are being dropped by their record companies due to low record sales.
Her voice hits my ear wrong. It's like screaming with a decent tonal quality. Not my cup of tea.
and HORRIBLE song choice!!!! It's an amazing song but why the **** would she choose that for idol? Speechless would have showcased her vocals better, if she wanted gaga. or a cool paparazzi arrangement.
She is forced to do it cuz Interscope want to promote the new album