|
Tournament: 5 Become 1: A Fifth Harmony Game - Round 2
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
Expect an update soon, all my ladies 'round the world.
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 8/11/2007
Posts: 63,796
|
naww wish I knew bout this
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
5 Become 1: A Fifth Harmony Game
[ROUND 1 RESULTS]
Welcome to the very first reveal of results for this game!
First of all, a word from one of our humble judges:
Quote:
Originally posted by shleven
Hi everyone! Just wanted to give a little introduction for my first round of judging. I know that many rounds in the game will require you to submit things that are ultimately up to personal preference, so I will try to give short comments on everybody's submission each round so you know why I ranked your entry high or low. Also, I can honestly say I don't consider myself to have a favourite or least favourite member of the group (and many 5H stans on ATRL will be able to attest to that), so never worry about your choice of girl affecting your position in my ranking! So with that, here's my Round 1 rankings!
|
I have already explained my work ethic previously, and KillingYourCareer is savage enough to not say an intro (in his defence I never asked him to have one) but let's start this already:
Revealing how each one of you did will be a bit different than how you're used to it in other games (for the ~suspense~ effect), so I hope you find this fun. Enough talk, let's get into it!
We will reveal the results in parts; every round will have a different pattern/flow of reveals. For this round, we are going like this:
I will reveal one of the five girls that is safe from elimination this round
(Thus the 2 players repping her are safe this round)
I will reveal the Best Performing Player overall in this round
(Thus is obviously safe)
I will reveal one of the bottom 3 players in this round
(Thus might end up on the chopping block)
I will reveal the Best Performing Girl [team]
(Thus the 2 players repping her are safe this round)
I will reveal a player that is safe this round
I will reveal the Worst Performing Girl [team]
(Thus the 2 players her might end up on the chopping block)
Out of the 3 in danger, I will reveal who is on The Chopping Block
(Aka the bottom 2, one of them will be eliminated after voting is done)
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
One of the five girls (and her respective players) did well enough to not be in danger this round, but not great enough to be the best this round. It doesn't matter really, because the players have ensured that their girl is safe this round...
...and as a result, the players representing the girl are safe, too...
...that girl is....
D I N A H
Congratulations URBAN and Lucky#17. You two are safe this round.
Statistics:
URBAN's performance:
59%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
The reason I LOVED your entry is because you were the only one who strayed away from the easy approach of sending a serious, model-like photo of your girl. The picture you chose not only is one where Dinah looks great, but it captures her personality as well, which is a step above everybody else. Great submission!
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
This was a risky choice, I love the vibrant aura this image of Dinah radiates as it matches her personality very well, but the other photoshoots were simply much more.. Epic? That's why this didn't get ranked that high for me. Still, good choice!
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Lucky#17's performance:
63%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
The photo itself is nice, but the reason I'm ranking it so low is because you can barely see Dinah in it. Between the outfit blending in too much with the car and her face being upside down, this picture could easily be of any random pretty girl instead of highlighting Dinah.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
Fierce and simple. Contrasts very well with the other photoshoots Dinah has (including the one submitted by your partner). Great choice.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
___
Dinah's overall performance:
61%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/17/2012
Posts: 17,268
|
Good job Team Dinah
Not sure if Starships is going to post the judges' full rankings later, but URBAN, your submission was my #1. I agree with Starships that it was a risky choice, but it paid off immensely in my opinion
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
Out of the 10 players, one incredibly stood out. The judges unaminously placed this member relatively high on their rankings...
....that player is.....
... a player representing.......
A L L Y
And that player is getback! Congratulations! You are the Best Performing Player this round. You are obviouslysafe this round. However, your girl can still be in danger as Squeeze's fate is still uncertain.
Statistics:
getback's performance:
78%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Ally really gets unfairly treated in the looks department, so I'm very happy you picked a photo that puts her beauty at the forefront. This is one of my favourite pictures of her, and one that immediately disproves the notion that she is not as beautiful as the other girls. If the Top 3 hadn't been so phenomenal, you would have definitely gotten a spot with this submission.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
I love this so much! I won't lie, I thought the other girls would totally snatch this round from Ally. Not to say she's not competent enough when it comes to photoshoots, but it's just that Ally's photoshoots aren't as glorified as the other girls' and it makes you think "does she really not have any good photoshoots?" But your entry totally disproves this, which is awesome.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Squeeze's performance:
??%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
???
|
___
Ally's overall performance:
??%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
Also out of the 10 players, one didn't do well at all. The judges unaminously placed this member relatively low on their rankings...
...did they do bad enough to end up on the chopping block? Or did they barely escape it?
......the first of our bottom 3 is a player representing.....
L A U R E N
And that player is Rian.! You are one of the worst performing players this round. You are in danger of ending up on the chopping block this round. However, you and your girl can still be safe if your partner did well enough to get you out of danger.
Statistics:
Rian.'s performance:
11%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
This is a shame because I looooooove this photo. Unfortunately, it didn't meet the criteria for the round, which asked for a photo from an official photoshoot, so I have no choice but to rank it at the bottom.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
What is this?
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Marvin's performance:
??%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
???
|
___
Lauren's overall performance:
??%
|
|
|
Member Since: 5/6/2012
Posts: 15,354
|
OMG yay Dinah is safe!!! Can't wait to see the rest of the results!
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 12/2/2010
Posts: 17,916
|
Yas! URBAN#17 our "Work from Home" era!
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/2/2012
Posts: 13,773
|
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
Now, we know Dinah is safe from elimination, so she's not the worst-performing girl for sure. But we also know she's not the best performing girl too.
Who could that be?
Which team had the best overall score?
The best performing girl is....
A L L Y
We previously revealed getback's performance, so let's see how their partner, Squeeze, fared. These two's work was consistently great making them the best performing team this round. Congrats! Squeeze, you are also safe this round. Ally can join Dinah in the safe-from-elimination club.
Statistics:
getback's performance:
78%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Ally really gets unfairly treated in the looks department, so I'm very happy you picked a photo that puts her beauty at the forefront. This is one of my favourite pictures of her, and one that immediately disproves the notion that she is not as beautiful as the other girls. If the Top 3 hadn't been so phenomenal, you would have definitely gotten a spot with this submission.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
I love this so much! I won't lie, I thought the other girls would totally snatch this round from Ally. Not to say she's not competent enough when it comes to photoshoots, but it's just that Ally's photoshoots aren't as glorified as the other girls' and it makes you think "does she really not have any good photoshoots?" But your entry totally disproves this, which is awesome.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Squeeze's performance:
56%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Unlike getback's photo, I find this picture doesn't really do much to highlight Ally. Her legs are in a strange position and you can't really see her face, so seeing this picture in passing wouldn't help me appreciate Ally and her beauty.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
his is okay. Not great, not terrible. Just okay
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
___
Ally's overall performance:
67%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
We know Dinah and Ally are safe. Lauren's fate is still up in the air.... But we haven't heard anything on Camila or Normani.
This next player to be revealed had one of the higher scores.
Could that player be representing Normani..?
....or Camila?
The player that had one of the higher scores is representing....
N O R M A N I
Congratulations, Jai! You are safe this round.
Statistics:
Jai's performance:
70%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
You and K$ have reminded me just how many great photoshoots Normani has had. This is also an amazing photo of her, but I'm ranking it slightly lower because it feels like too much of a "safe" choice for me; she looks great, but nothing really stands out.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
A safe choice, but a damn good one.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
K$Ellie performance:
??%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
???
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
___
Normani's overall performance:
??%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
Let's recap very quickly: URBAN, Lucky#17, getback, Squeeze and Jai are safe.
Rian. is one of the bottom 3.
This leaves us with Marvin (Lauren), K$Ellie (Normani), Diarrhoea (Camila) and Pedro (Camila)
One of these four was the second best performing player..
We will reveal that player later.
Because now is the time to reveal the worst performing team.
I think you've figured it out.
The worst performing team is the one representing.....
C A M I L A
Sadly, both Diarrhoea and Pedro are going to join Rian. in the bottom 3 of this round.
Statistics:
Diarrhoea's performance:
33%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Similarly to Jai's entry, I do like this picture (although I do think there are many better pictures of Camila, so I'm quite surprised that both of you thought to submit this one), but I found it to be safe. Nothing wrong, but nothing really stood out for me.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
This is okay but is this really Camila's best..?
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Pedro's performance:
33%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Similarly to Jai's entry, I do like this picture (although I do think there are many better pictures of Camila, so I'm quite surprised that both of you thought to submit this one), but I found it to be safe. Nothing wrong, but nothing really stood out for me.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
What I said to Diarrhoea's entry 2.0
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
___
Camila's overall performance:
17%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
We only have two players left. Marvin (Lauren) and K$Ellie (Normani)
I'm pleased to announce that......
The player that was the second best performing player this round was representing....
L A U R E N
Marvin, you did amazingly well this round. You are obviously safe this round. However, your teammate is in danger of ending up on the chopping block putting your girl in danger. So let's see how that pans out, but for now, enjoy your performance below!
Statistics:
Rian.'s performance:
11%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
This is a shame because I looooooove this photo. Unfortunately, it didn't meet the criteria for the round, which asked for a photo from an official photoshoot, so I have no choice but to rank it at the bottom.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
What is this?
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
Marvin's performance:
74%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
Frankly, I would have been disappointed if one of the two Lauren players hadn't picked this photo. It's definitely one of Lauren's best photos ever, and like how K$ showed with Mani, this picture really captures Lauren's boldness and sharp look.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
Immaculate.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
???
|
___
Lauren's overall performance:
43%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
The only girl that we don't know how she performed overall is Normani, so let's take a look at her overall performance (and K$Ellie's)
N O R M A N I
Congratulations, K$Ellie! You are also safe this round.
Statistics:
Jai's performance:
70%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
You and K$ have reminded me just how many great photoshoots Normani has had. This is also an amazing photo of her, but I'm ranking it slightly lower because it feels like too much of a "safe" choice for me; she looks great, but nothing really stands out.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
A safe choice, but a damn good one.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
____
K$Ellie performance:
56%
Judges Comments:
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
In addition to the fact that Mani looks AMAZING in this photo, I like how you chose a picture that captures how she is so fashionably adventurous. This photo immediately stood out at me when I was looking through the photos, and that kind of boldness and uniqueness is part of what defines Normani. Great choice.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
Normani in a nutshell. Captures her good, but your competition is stronger.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
N/A
|
___
Normani's overall performance:
63%
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
So, who of these three will will end up on the chopping block?
Let's remind everyone how the chopping block works: Two players get on it, and then the safe players send me a PM choosing to save one of the two players. Your votes will be ANONYMOUS. When the votes are collected, the player with the least votes is eliminated from the game.
Next post we will reveal who is safe from these three, who will get on the chopping block and the overall rankings from the judges.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 8,249
|
ROUND 1 RESULTS
Judges Rankings (best to worst):
Quote:
Originally posted by Starships
9. Lucky#17
8. Marvin
7. Jai
6. getback
5. K$Ellie
4. Squeeze
3. URBAN
2. Diarrhoea / Pedro
1. Rian.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by KillingYourCareer
9. getback
8. Squeeze
7. Jai
6. Lucky#17
5. Marvin
4. URBAN
3. Diarrhoea / Pedro
2. K$Ellie
1. Rian.
|
Quote:
Originally posted by shelven
9. URBAN
8. K$Ellie
7. Marvin
6. getback
5. Jai
4. Diarrhoea / Pedro
3. Squeeze
2. Lucky#17
1. Rian.
|
Overall rankings:
Quote:
1. getback
2. Marvin
3. Jai
4. Lucky#17
5. URBAN
6. K$Ellie & Squeeze
7. Diarrhoea & Pedro
8. Rian.
|
After applying the same entry penalty:
Quote:
1. getback
2. Marvin
3. Jai
4. Lucky#17
5. URBAN
6. K$Ellie & Squeeze
7. Rian.
8. Diarrhoea & Pedro
|
Overall girl ranking (best to worst):
Quote:
1. Ally
2. Normani
3. Dinah
4. Lauren
5. Camila
|
So with that...
Pedro (Camila) and Diarrhoea (Camila) are on the chopping block.
The other 8 safe players, please send me a PM indicating who of these two you would like to save. Please do it asap as it doesn't take long!
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/6/2015
Posts: 1,629
|
Can we see the pictures that they submitted?
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 39,572
|
My strategy worked!
|
|
|
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 8/11/2007
Posts: 63,796
|
No not my girl cam having 2 pics in the bottom, what y'all doing hoes
|
|
|
|
|