|
Poll: Whos Career Is Thriving More? Justin vs Selena
View Poll Results: .
|
Justin
|
|
32 |
50.00% |
Selena
|
|
32 |
50.00% |
Member Since: 8/17/2011
Posts: 3,613
|
Quote:
Currently browsing: 10 members (___littlered, themusictoblame, labelmanBEP, RihSexual, mileysus, Braz), 83 guests.
|
Why so many guests?
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/26/2011
Posts: 14,707
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
OMG! No one is talking about SUCCESS darling. The word is THRIVING look it up. Whose career is growing at the moment. Idc, how much he or she sold that's success and sales. We're not talking about that. Also I'm not talking about Justin's past, we're talking about RIGHT NOW and right now Selena is more stable as far as versatility and thriving goes in her career than he is.
|
Quote:
we're talking about RIGHT NOW
|
And right now Selena still isn't getting that top twenty single, that #1 album, that platinum album, that $30 million grossing tour, that hit movie that isn't animated, or those magazine covers. Nearly every one of my receipts are 2012 recent so yes, we are talking about right now, and right now Justin's career is thriving more than Selena's.
But if you really want to talk about right now, let's talk Selena's most recent magazine covers where Justin's name is plastered on the front.
So much for that thriving career you speak of. I'm done.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Lovatostan
In what WAY is her career is growing? Justin destroyed her in every single part last year and this year.
Believe sold almost 3M WW, that's almost all of her albums combined and his last single went Top 10 while Selena's last single didn't even CHART.
Its obviously Justin, Selena's career isn't growing but Justin is growing hence why he's getting top 10 singles, more radio support, sold out stadiums, etc.
I don't see Selena doing it and I don't see her "Nail Polish" or "Perfume" breaking records.
|
Again you're talking about sales. I don't care about that nor is that the question. Mainly I'm talking about in her career OVERALL, and she has a lot more going on which shows she is thriving, and growing. I'll have to check on her nail polish and perfume (I don't keep up with sales obviously, lol) so for now that's the only thing valid you have against my viewpoint.
|
|
|
Member Since: 8/10/2012
Posts: 4,484
|
Quote:
Originally posted by pika
And right now Selena still isn't getting that top twenty single, that #1 album, that platinum album, that $30 million grossing tour, that hit movie that isn't animated, or those magazine covers. Nearly every one of my receipts are 2012 recent so yes, we are talking about right now, and right now Justin's career is thriving more than Selena's.
But if you really want to talk about right now, let's talk Selena's most recent magazine covers where Justin's name is plastered on the front.
So much for that thriving career you speak of. I'm done.
|
I'm DONE pika
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by pika
And right now Selena still isn't getting that top twenty single, that #1 album, that platinum album, that $30 million grossing tour, that hit movie that isn't animated, or those magazine covers. Nearly every one of my receipts are 2012 recent so yes, we are talking about right now, and right now Justin's career is thriving more than Selena's.
But if you really want to talk about right now, let's talk Selena's most recent magazine covers where Justin's name is plastered on the front.
So much for that thriving career you speak of. I'm done.
|
Did I not make it clear that I am NOT talking about success nor is the OP from my viewpoint and the main word"THRIVING" and it's definition, already for the millionth time? We'll see when she releases her single what will happen which is something I kinda previously stated if you'd bother to read. Justin is on tour so therefore this really isn't even a fair comparison on HIS part. He has NOTHING going on at the moment aside from his movie with Mark Wahlberg and a tour. Also, Justin can't sell his own magazines so why would his fans or OLDER readers for that matter buy hers? Older women don't care for Bieber and THEY'RE the main demographic for those magazines so there you have it.
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/7/2011
Posts: 41,996
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
Again you're talking about sales. I don't care about that nor is that the question. Mainly I'm talking about in her career OVERALL, and she has a lot more going on which shows she is thriving, and growing. I'll have to check on her nail polish and perfume (I don't keep up with sales obviously, lol) so for now that's the only thing valid you have against my viewpoint.
|
You have failed again to prove a receipt of Selena's career "thriving" more.
The only thing she has going on is her "movie" and we still have yet to see how is it going to do on box office.
Justin has his tour which is doing absolutely amazing and his single being sent to radio recently.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/1/2012
Posts: 2,748
|
Quote:
Originally posted by YeaBey4ever
|
Off topic, but don't you just love these fluff pieces? Like we're supposed to believe a 19 year old who can't write a grammatically correct letter is some kind of business wiz. I'd guarantee 90% of the celebs out there have people handling their money for them and they just sign off on whatever investments their financial experts recommend.
Anyways, I'd say Justin right now. I think in some segments of the GP Selena is best known as Justin's ex. However, I think it's possible that she could really break out this era in a big way.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/10/2012
Posts: 1,408
|
Well, acting and music are two different industries...it's not really a fair comparison. Music = Justin, acting = Selena.
Quote:
Originally posted by Pie-kun
Off topic, but don't you just love these fluff pieces? Like we're supposed to believe a 19 year old who can't write a grammatically correct letter is some kind of business wiz. I'd guarantee 90% of the celebs out there have people handling their money for them and they just sign off on whatever investments their financial experts recommend.
|
The article actually stated that Justin isn't in full control of the business side of things instead of giving him full credit if I recall. His team come to him with things they think he'd be interested investing in and he makes the decision, but it's still coming from his pocket. He's still enthusiastic about the projects though, especially Instagram lmao.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/7/2012
Posts: 22
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
Did I not make it clear that I am NOT talking about success nor is the OP from my viewpoint and the main word"THRIVING" and it's definition, already for the millionth time? We'll see when she releases her single what will happen which is something I kinda previously stated if you'd bother to read. Justin is on tour so therefore this really isn't even a fair comparison on HIS part. He has NOTHING going on at the moment aside from his movie with Mark Wahlberg and a tour. Also, Justin can't sell his own magazines so why would his fans or OLDER readers for that matter buy hers? Older women don't care for Bieber and THEY'RE the main demographic for those magazines so there you have it.
|
so essentially your definition of a thriving career is "who currently has more projects lined up on March 17, 2013? are you redefining "thriving," because i don't see why someone who is on a sold out world tour and just got yet another top 10 multiplatinum single wouldn't be considered to be thriving. selena can release eighty movies starring ex nickelodeon stars if she wants, that doesn't mean her career is thriving unless you subjectively redefine success...
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Lovatostan
You have failed again to prove a receipt of Selena's career "thriving" more.
The only thing she has going on is her "movie" and we still have yet to see how is it going to do on box office.
Justin has his tour which is doing absolutely amazing and his single being sent to radio recently.
|
She's getting offered more movie roles as we speak says, Ken Baker who works at E! so therefore it's a stable that her movie career should be going somewhere. That's thriving hun. She has 4 movies (including Aftershock cameo) and SB is doing quite well overseas and here (ask the other stans I've said that I don't keep up with sales and such). There you have that, as in she is growing as an actress. Congrats for him and his tour though.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 3,480
|
Lol Justin's career have thrived l. These past few weeks won't hurt him, the same people that hated him before are the same people that are saying his career is going downhill. The other one may have some success with acting
|
|
|
Member Since: 6/7/2011
Posts: 41,996
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
She's getting offered more movie roles as we speak says, Ken Baker who works at E! so therefore it's a stable that her movie career should be going somewhere. That's thriving hun. She has 4 movies (including Aftershock cameo) and SB is doing quite well overseas and here (ask the other stans I've said that I don't keep up with sales and such). There you have that, as in she is growing as an actress. Congrats for him and his tour though.
|
So your definition of thriving is having more projects? Alright...
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 8,406
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Lovatostan
So your definition of thriving is having more projects? Alright...
|
I'm glad my fave has so many projects.. I'm so excited
|
|
|
Member Since: 12/26/2011
Posts: 14,707
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
Did I not make it clear that I am NOT talking about success nor is the OP from my viewpoint and the main word"THRIVING" and it's definition, already for the millionth time? We'll see when she releases her single what will happen which is something I kinda previously stated if you'd bother to read. Justin is on tour so therefore this really isn't even a fair comparison on HIS part. He has NOTHING going on at the moment aside from his movie with Mark Wahlberg and a tour. Also, Justin can't sell his own magazines so why would his fans or OLDER readers for that matter buy hers? Older women don't care for Bieber and THEY'RE the main demographic for those magazines so there you have it.
|
Selena doing more projects = her career is thriving more? Tons of washed up celebrities do projects but their careers aren't thriving. Lady Gaga is only touring right now, is her career not thriving? Katy Perry isn't doing anything at the moment, is her career not thriving? Your logic makes no sense because it's backed up by absolutely nothing. The receipts all point to Justin's career thriving more as of right now. His tour sold more tickets than Selena's tours as of right now, his album sell more than hers as of right now his fragrances and perfumes were bigger than hers, he covers more prestigious magazines, so what is your point exactly?
How can somebody who's known as being somebodies ex-girlfriend be thriving more career wise?
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by takeyou
so essentially your definition of a thriving career is "who currently has more projects lined up on March 17, 2013? are you redefining "thriving," because i don't see why someone who is on a sold out world tour and just got yet another top 10 multiplatinum single wouldn't be considered to be thriving. selena can release eighty movies starring ex nickelodeon stars if she wants, that doesn't mean her career is thriving unless you subjectively redefine success...
|
OMG! I'm not trying to say that he isn't but is he growing is what I'm saying, like someone else and MYSELF mentioned this is a bit of an unfair comparison. However, that's success and sales which can be thriving obviously but mainly GROWING is what I'm talking about. Selena is growing in her craft whereas Justin is being his usual self and hasn't really done anything different if you understand me. Her career is thriving because it's a step in the right direction and she's growing. I'm just saying that from the way it looks, it seems she's going to thrive more than he is because she has a lot more going on. I'm not denying his success but it's not a major part of thriving so I'd appreciate if we stop with the sales and tours.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 8,406
|
Quote:
Originally posted by pika
Selena doing more projects = her career is thriving more? Tons of washed up celebrities do projects but their careers aren't thriving. Lady Gaga is only touring right now, is her career not thriving? Katy Perry isn't doing anything at the moment, is her career not thriving? Your logic makes no sense because it's backed up by absolutely nothing. The receipts all point to Justin's career thriving more as of right now. His tour sold more tickets than Selena's tours as of right now, his album sell more than hers as of right now his fragrances and perfumes were bigger than hers, he covers more prestigious magazines, so what is your point exactly?
How can somebody who's known as being somebodies ex-girlfriend be thriving more career wise?
|
at the last part of this post.. most of the press selena is getting right now has nothing to do with justin
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Lovatostan
So your definition of thriving is having more projects? Alright...
|
No, but it seems that with him being on tour and her doing movies,music and more if you compare the 2 you can see which one is growing the most, that's what thriving is.
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 8,406
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
OMG! I'm not trying to say that he isn't but is he growing is what I'm saying, like someone else and MYSELF mentioned this is a bit of an unfair comparison. However, that's success and sales which can be thriving obviously but mainly GROWING is what I'm talking about. Selena is growing in her craft whereas Justin is being his usual self and hasn't really done anything different if you understand me. Her career is thriving because it's a step in the right direction and she's growing. I'm just saying that from the way it looks, it seems she's going to thrive more than he is because she has a lot more going on. I'm not denying his success but it's not a major part of thriving so I'd appreciate if we stop with the sales and tours.
|
Everyone knows Selena is thriving too right now & if they say she isn't they are probably in denial or delusional. they're both very successful people
|
|
|
Member Since: 3/15/2013
Posts: 1,882
|
Quote:
Originally posted by pika
Selena doing more projects = her career is thriving more? Tons of washed up celebrities do projects but their careers aren't thriving. Lady Gaga is only touring right now, is her career not thriving? Katy Perry isn't doing anything at the moment, is her career not thriving? Your logic makes no sense because it's backed up by absolutely nothing. The receipts all point to Justin's career thriving more as of right now. His tour sold more tickets than Selena's tours as of right now, his album sell more than hers as of right now his fragrances and perfumes were bigger than hers, he covers more prestigious magazines, so what is your point exactly?
How can somebody who's known as being somebodies ex-girlfriend be thriving more career wise?
|
You tell me! I don't care about that whole Justin Biebers ex thing, that is OLD and that's all you have to bring up. I'm just saying how it looks to me when you compare JUSTIN and SELENA, it's really not a fair comparison but if I had to answer, it'd be Selena. I'm not even concerned with Justin so I'm kinda just saying that I see Selena growing and I'm not really answering the question, so that's a problem on my part. I just don't see how you can compare the 2.
|
|
|
Member Since: 9/7/2012
Posts: 22
|
Quote:
Originally posted by Kala
Selena is growing in her craft whereas Justin is being his usual self and hasn't really done anything different if you understand me..
|
and this is based on what, exactly? her performance in spring breakers, which is getting mixed reviews at best? you won't know if she's thriving until she actually releases anything and there's a performance to measure. this argument is pointless.
|
|
|
|
|