[DripDrip]

GaGa is pop culture, Miley is a steet show that gets talked about for a few months then people get bored with and move on.

[Arking]

Originally posted by BadBitches

Being the first white female to ever twerk with no ass, whilst rubbing up against a 36 year old married man.

The impact. The artistry. The backlash. The "controversy."

[BabyCantYouSee]

Originally posted by TREMendo

as will everything Miley did.



Are you guys really contemplating the answer to this, ARE YOU SERIOUS?

I'm am taken aback at the extreme ridiculousness that i'm reading, Miley > Gaga, HA!!
that is astonishing how impressionable you guys really are and the way that fads work on the feeble minded individuals that don't understand the difference between a controversial stunt and creating and maintaining a rave, maintaining relevance in such an "ADD" driven culture. Her little stunt will be begin her own demise, she ultimately broke away from what made her popular, any responsible parent will cut off their children from her, hence taking away her ENTIRE FOLLOWING - CHILDREN, young adults til the age of probably 17, 18 who at that age already are weening off of HANNAH MONTANA, which is her salvation and her damnation.

I digress.

Calm down guy.

[Aphrodite]

Gaga...

I mean, c'mon

[ryanpittman97]

Originally posted by TREMendo

Miley > Gaga

As long as you know

[JessicaVanessa]

Originally posted by BadBitches

Gaga. She made Katy, Nicki and all the other pop gurls try and up their games. Miley is a silly faze. Just like puberty.

*phase.

[Harajuku]

Gaga is probably laughing her ass off lurking this thread.

[memi stan]

Originally posted by TREMendo

as will everything Miley did.



Are you guys really contemplating the answer to this, ARE YOU SERIOUS?

I'm am taken aback at the extreme ridiculousness that i'm reading, Miley > Gaga, HA!!
that is astonishing how impressionable you guys really are and the way that fads work on the feeble minded individuals that don't understand the difference between a controversial stunt and creating and maintaining a rave, maintaining relevance in such an "ADD" driven culture. Her little stunt will be begin her own demise, she ultimately broke away from what made her popular, any responsible parent will cut off their children from her, hence taking away her ENTIRE FOLLOWING - CHILDREN, young adults til the age of probably 17, 18 who at that age already are weening off of HANNAH MONTANA, which is her salvation and her damnation.

I digress.



Bite, chew, regurgitate, repeat, learn.

GaGa was a fad though. Miley has at least been around for a long time.

[Yzma]

Gaga>>>>>>>>>>Hannah Montana>>>>>>>Miley Cyrus.

[Bimbo]

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

How so? All of the post made by us so far have been nothing but that truth that certain members fail to realize.

...

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

Which was more talked about, more memorable, more controversial, and more iconic than anything Gaga has ever done.

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

Seemingly all forgotten

dd ok

[Indigo Blue]

Gaga

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by memi stan

GaGa was a fad though. Miley has at least been around for a long time.

Fad: An intense and widely shared enthusiasm for something, esp. one that is short-lived and without basis in the object's qualities; a craze

I think she's broken that barrier already, Ke$ha, fad, in and out with a bang.. but done.
Gaga is far from done. Without the help of the best marketing-driven company in the world DISNEY, he will make any penny off of anything possible.

Miley should've been bigger - how do you say it, "bookmark" this, in a year from todays date... she'll be the "ehhh" of 2013.

and if separate them, Hannah Montana > Miley
her persona was and will always be more famous than who she is.

Sad reality.

[FlyOnTheWall]

I hate when people say "If we include Hannah"... Why shouldn't we? It's part of her ****ing career, and that part alone is bigger than most things today's pop girls ever did.

[Praise Mariallah]

Originally posted by FlyOnTheWall

I hate when people say "If we include Hannah"... Why shouldn't we? It's part of her ****ing career, and that part alone is bigger than most things today's pop girls ever did.

Because it was created, promoted, marketed, etc all by Disney.

Miley herself had no hand in it; in the greater aspect of things.

Miley just happened to be the one chosen for the role.

It would be the same if Nickelodeon created "Lady Gaga" for Stefani.

And it also wasn't just music but a tv show and brand which had anything from bookbags to lunchboxes.

Miley is also benefiting immensely NOW from Hannah Montana/Disney just because her image change is so drastic people are captivated. She wouldn't have taken this year by storm if she was completely new, fresh outta nowhere. There wouldn't have been a twerk scandal or phenomenon. That's the difference between her and Gags. Gaga did it from scratch.

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

Because it was created, promoted, marketed, etc all by Disney.

Miley herself had no hand in it; in the greater aspect of things.

Miley just happened to be the one chosen for the role.

It would be the same if Nickelodeon created "Lady Gaga" for Stefani.

And it also wasn't just music but a tv show and brand which had anything from bookbags to lunchboxes.

Miley is also benefiting immensely NOW from Hannah Montana/Disney just because her image change is so drastic people are captivated. She wouldn't have taken this year by storm if she was completely new, fresh outta nowhere. There wouldn't have been a twerk scandal or phenomenon. That's the difference between her and Gags. Gaga did it from scratch.

Somebody gets it (:

Kudos Kudos!

[memi stan]

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

Because it was created, promoted, marketed, etc all by Disney.

Miley herself had no hand in it; in the greater aspect of things.

Miley just happened to be the one chosen for the role.

It would be the same if Nickelodeon created "Lady Gaga" for Stefani.

And it also wasn't just music but a tv show and brand which had anything from bookbags to lunchboxes.

Miley is also benefiting immensely NOW from Hannah Montana/Disney just because her image change is so drastic people are captivated. She wouldn't have taken this year by storm if she was completely new, fresh outta nowhere. There wouldn't have been a twerk scandal or phenomenon. That's the difference between her and Gags. Gaga did it from scratch.

Miley made Hannah Montana huge though. It wouldn't have been nearly as big with someone else. I was never a fan of Hannah Montana the show but her voice and personality got me interested in her music. I don't even use the hannah songs for the most part.

[ToxDuris]

Originally posted by ryanpittman97

The VMA's alone is more iconic and memorable than anything Gaga has done TBH.

THIS!
Nothing Gaga has ever done is more iconic than her VMA performance.

[TREMendo]

Originally posted by memi stan

Miley made Hannah Montana huge though. It wouldn't have been nearly as big with someone else. I was never a fan of Hannah Montana the show but her voice and personality got me interested in her music. I don't even use the hanna songs for the most part.

I think Disney has already proven themselves to make anyone they want BIG.





if it wasn't Miley, they have a whole arsenal of girls that would've done the same thing...

[MaRy]

Originally posted by Praise Mariallah

Because it was created, promoted, marketed, etc all by Disney.

Miley herself had no hand in it; in the greater aspect of things.

Miley just happened to be the one chosen for the role.

It would be the same if Nickelodeon created "Lady Gaga" for Stefani.

And it also wasn't just music but a tv show and brand which had anything from bookbags to lunchboxes.

Miley is also benefiting immensely NOW from Hannah Montana/Disney just because her image change is so drastic people are captivated. She wouldn't have taken this year by storm if she was completely new, fresh outta nowhere. There wouldn't have been a twerk scandal or phenomenon. That's the difference between her and Gags. Gaga did it from scratch.

Every popstar debut is created marketed and manufactured by the record label . And the fact that it's a tv show is irrelevant because I asked about cultural impact

[Almighty Gaga]

Gaga and it's not even close.