Gonna bring it all the way back to when Yahhh!!! staged a prank on ATRL and the website was "shut down by the FBI" for violating piracy. We thought ATRL was gone for good.
I spent hours reading the Natalia Kills thread and literally cried at some of the jokes. One of the weirdest and funniest topics and ATRL delivered the kiis
As far as biggest threads go the Kim exposing Taylor Swift is up there but when I was lurking the Applause vs Roar, Prism vs. Artpop and BEYONCE drop were pretty iconic
My biggest thread about the 23 year old boiling to death and my other hit thread about fathers/parents setting of gaydars were also iconic