Don't raise your tone at me Andrais Jonathan Smith.
Let me stop playing before Orange comes in here and tries to clock me for fake fighting with my friends again.
I will gladly let Orange clock you.
There is honestly no need for the Base section. I already see it turning into a whole section for SYG related material.
Usually the album thread or an upcoming album discussion is a home to a fanbase, and then just adding another one makes it feel a little pointless.
EDIT: I also don't like the polls back to being in whatever section they're posted.
I think it's confusing having general artist discussions with grouped discussions which compare multiple artists. Wasn't that the point of creating the lounge? It creates too much competition for threads.
Hmm... I think it's best for off-era discussion of major artists, also to get the off-topic posts out of the album and single threads during in-era discussion. But I don't think every no-name artist who ever lived deserves one.
I don't know, so far I like everything about "Base" except the actual Fan Base threads. Something's not sitting right about them. I think we just need to wait for the irrelevants to drop down and out of Page 1.
I agree, the fan base threads should not dominate the whole forum. They're only meant as a replacement for the huge threads in music news.
That's what we used RT for. Y'all are just gonna kill other sections of the site with this idea, especially Music News. Whenever an era ends you all just close the Album Threads, but what if we still want to discuss current eras? We obviously can't talk about them in the Lounge anymore and obviously not Base since that section is apparently for general artist discussion not involving current eras.
What is the point about complaining about Base now? It hasn't even been active for a day. See how it all works out. Speculating about it killing other sections is pretty pointless.
That's what we used RT for. Y'all are just gonna kill other sections of the site with this idea, especially Music News. Whenever an era ends you all just close the Album Threads, but what if we still want to discuss current eras? We obviously can't talk about them in the Lounge anymore and obviously not Base since that section is apparently for general artist discussion not involving current eras.
Music News could not go on the way it was. The album threads were too much of a mess. This is only the first step to a new, more organized ATRL. We will see how it works out and adapt accordingly.
Music News could not go on the way it was. The album threads were too much of a mess. This is only the first step to a new, more organized ATRL. We will see how it works out and adapt accordingly.
Yeah, remember when Music News actually used to have individual headlines when stuff happened? I don't know when the album threads took over but that really changed the way it used to be. I guess that's the next thing to fix.
What about discussing only chart related, singles, etc in the album threads and anything else about the artist, not only about the current album era or the music, in the Base threads?
I would recommend removing the album threads altogether.
Make the base the place where ALL discussion related to the artist goes in their thread. No matter what era.
They might as well just delete Music News completely then.
Quote:
Originally posted by Loghen
What about discussing only chart related, singles, etc in the album threads and anything else about the artist, not only about the current album era or the music, in the Base threads?
Just about every relevant artist on ATRL has their own Chart thread in the Chart section where we post those kinds of things already.