Discussion: Bigger career: Hilary Duff or Selena Gomez? - Page 3

Jeffsuxx

this is about bigger career tho.. and selena won a VMA has more awards and she has an EMMY

but this is really hard for me i love both... hilary is still the queen of disney and no one can deny ha impact..

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by 4seldemari

Selena Gomez

- sold more singles
- has had more of an impact
- is more known worldwide
- Wizards of Waverly Place was more critically and commercially received than Lizzie McGuire
- acting career has had more longevity and success

Hillary Duff

- sold more albums
- I've only heard one or two songs from her (With Love and Wake Up)
- doesn't have a song that's platinum whereas Selena has multiple (nearly all except one)
- her acting career isn't very successful currently

I like Hillary I'm just sharing my opinion so please don't hate. We can talk this out without conflict.

- Hilary sold more albums
- Hilary grossed more with her tours
- She have more than 1 top 10 hit in the UK
- Hilary's movies were more successful than Selena's
- Hilary's net worth: $25 million > Selena's 16 million

- Selena sold more singles
- Selena have a top 10 single in the US
- Selena is more known currently because she's younger and her career is smaller than Hilary's

I still think Hilary wins overall!

Jeffsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Ultraviolence

I wouldn't know, the only thing I use from her is the chorus to Slow Down.

sad to heard that.. cuz stars dance was one of the best pop albums of 2013

enjoy

Jeffsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

- Hilary sold more albums
- Hilary grossed more with her tours
- She have more than 1 top 10 hit in the UK
- Her movies were mote successful than Selena's
- Hilary's net worth: $25 million > Selena's 16 million

- Selena sold more singles
- Selena have a top 10 single in the US
- Selena is more known currently because she's younger and her career is smaller than Hilary's

I still think Hilary wins overall!

selena and hilary are tied w 2 or 3 i dont remember top 10 hits in the uk

and how do you know that hilary grossed more with her tours??

im still waiting for ALL selena's tour gross

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Jeffsuxx

selena and hilary are tie w 2 or 3 i dont remember top 10 hits in the uk

and how do you know that hilary grossed more with her tours??

im still waiting for ALL selena's tour gross

Just accept that Hilary was bigger than Selena at her peak, Hilary did much MORE than Selena is doing right now

4seldemari

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

Selena's Stars Dance Tour(not complete sure):
Total: 20.3 million

Hilary:
Most Wanted Tour: 30 million
Still Most Wanted Tour: 67 million
Dignity Tour: 30 million

Total: 127 million

Well is not far to compare this because Selena doesn't have more WW tours right? Well Hilary still grossed more with all her tours...

Wait so you're not going to include her tours with The Scene?

Selena Gomez:
Selena Gomez Live in Concert: 0.2 million
A Year Without Rain Tour: 3.2 million
We Own the Night: 34.4 million
Stars Dance: 20.4 million

Total: 58.2 million (please keep in mind that the first two had no seat capacity past 6k and were practically sold out of that...)

Hillary Duff: (you forgot Metamorphosis)
Metamorphosis: 10 million
Most Wanted Tour: 30 million
Still Most Wanted Tour: 67 million
Dignity Tour: 30 million

Total: 177 million

The first two weren't even "real" tours but we'll go with it

4seldemari

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

Just accept that Hilary was bigger than Selena at her peak, Hilary did much MORE than Selena is doing right now

Does Hillary have any single that's certified at least platinum never mind 2x, 3x, and 4x platinum? You can say that when she does.

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by 4seldemari

Wait so you're not going to include her tours with The Scene?

Selena Gomez:
Selena Gomez Live in Concert: 0.2 million
A Year Without Rain Tour: 3.2 million
We Own the Night: 34.4 million
Stars Dance: 20.4 million

Total: 58.2 million (please keep in mind that the first two had no seat capacity past 6k and were practically sold out of that...)

Hillary Duff: (you forgot Metamorphosis)
Metamorphosis: 10 million
Most Wanted Tour: 30 million
Still Most Wanted Tour: 67 million
Dignity Tour: 30 million

Total: 177 million

The first two weren't even "real" tours but we'll go with it

I didn't know she toured before her solo album sorry, but looking at the receipts, Hilary wins right?

Jeffsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

Just accept that Hilary was bigger than Selena at her peak, Hilary did much MORE than Selena is doing right now

not really ..her and selena are quite similar with the success and all that.. the only different thing is that hilary sold more albums/movies.. but selena got way more fame ....

its almost a tie.. but hilary wins...

but lets see if hilary can have success again..

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by 4seldemari

Does Hillary have any single that's certified at least platinum never mind 2x, 3x, and 4x platinum? You can say that when she does.

She doesn't because her singles were released before the digital era.

Jeffsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

She doesn't because her singles were released before the digital era.

what about with love? stranger and reach out?

conatus

hilary

Anticipating

Quote:

Originally posted by 4seldemari

Selena Gomez:
Selena Gomez Live in Concert: 0.2 million
A Year Without Rain Tour: 3.2 million
We Own the Night: 34.4 million
Stars Dance: 20.4 million

Hillary Duff: (you forgot Metamorphosis)
Metamorphosis: 10 million
Most Wanted Tour: 30 million
Still Most Wanted Tour: 67 million
Dignity Tour: 30 million

Hilary's tour gross is made up by her stans, Selena probably wins in that departament too.

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Jeffsuxx

what about with love? stranger and reach out?

How can these singles sell with her 0 airplay and lack of promo?

And do you remember Hollywood Records ruined her career?

4seldemari

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

I didn't know she toured before her solo album sorry, but looking at the receipts, Hilary wins right?

Yes you are 100% right looking at the receipts Hillary does WIN but because she's had two more tours but she did win.

Jeffsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

How can these singles sell with her 0 airplay and lack of promo?

And do you remember Hollywood Records ruined her career?

tell me something i dont know wasnt even a single.. and It has sold over 1M copies .

4seldemari

Quote:

Originally posted by gerardsuxx

How can these singles sell with her 0 airplay and lack of promo?

And do you remember Hollywood Records ruined her career?

With Love was one of the few songs I remember from her though. And by far my fave.

MikeyDuff1D

Quote:

Originally posted by Work Bitch

Hilary's tour gross is made up by her stans, Selena probably wins in that departament too.

Actually, Hilary's tour gross was made up by Wikipedia.

gerardsuxx

Quote:

Originally posted by Work Bitch

Hilary's tour gross is made up by her stans, Selena probably wins in that departament too.

http://www.tourintel.com/report_arti...5709#tab-gross

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilar..._concert_tours I'm almost sure you don't have an account there so you can see here

4seldemari

Quote:

Originally posted by Jeffsuxx

tell me something i dont know wasnt even a single.. and It has sold over 1M copies in the us..

OMG I just realized that! It sold more than one of the actual singles. Ha!

Back on topic...I've always wondered why Hillary was never very good in the singles category because her album sales were very high.