[Misanthrope]

ATRL as usual doing the most with Gaga. Her detractors are so damn loud that this thread is more like another meeting of the gaga-hating minds to discuss everything they think shes doing wrong and rub it in the faces of the fans because they love to jerk eachother off with little monster tears of sadness and frustration as lube and c*m in orgy to the thought of her failing even if shes yet to be the true trainwreck they want her to be.

The album is literally doing adequate. Nothing more, nothing less.

[Diocles]

Nope. sorry.

[romonster]

Originally posted by ElleDriver

Yes, I don't see how it's not.

[The Unforgiving]

nah

[BoyOnBoy Wonder]

Nope.

[One Nation]

Yes.

Million Reasons has stalled on radio and Joanne will struggle to reach 500k in US pure sales.

[retromaury]

absolutely.

so much effort and money was put into promoting it and the numbers just arent adding up.

[Green]

Well it's not a big sucess, but it's not a huge flop neither.

Its performance is similar to Frank Ocean's album

[KORDEI]

Cap10, your OP is so nicely worded. You almost sound like they do when they say that it being at a measly 600k after like a month is "great" and better than "we all expected"

[jagger88788]

Yes. I'm dead at the monsters trying to convince themselves the album is a success

No one's here for corny country music

[istan4badgalriri]

Originally posted by IBeMe

Not really. It is doing ok. Not a commercial juggernaut but not a failure either. She will end up going Gold in sales and platinum in streams which is ok to good.

Also these are the stats so far:

US SPS: Nearing 400,000 units
US Pure Sales: About to reach 300,000 copies
Worldwide: About to surpass 600,000 copies

Not a slay but not a flop either tbh.

That's bad considering she's dicscounted the singles and the album several times and she's promoted the album on:

- GMA
- SNL
- Carpool Karaoke
- AMAs
- CBS
- The Late Late Show

+ Countless radio interviews & Japan promo. She's had the Super Bowl hype/announcement as well.

The album is at 525k WW according to MT, not 600k.

[QueenB4]

Originally posted by Green

Well it's not a big sucess, but it's not a huge flop neither.

Its performance is similar to Frank Ocean's album

Considering how much of a bigger artist/name Gaga is, this is completely worrying.

[Mark Rih]

ATRL doesn't wish anything lol. The era is a tragedy for real. PI and MR are two of the biggest flops ever.

[White_King]

It's not a smash it's a slight under performance
Not a total bomb a la Bionic though

[careerfatality]

Originally posted by jagger88788

Yes. I'm dead at the monsters trying to convince themselves the album is a success

No one's here for corny country music

kesha • marina • natalia • halsey • tove lo • twenty one pilots

[Kings.]

No

[DripDrip]

For all the big promo she did sort of yah.

[nick4bty]

These same people were expecting an opening week of 100k or less and now they're saying 500k is bad?

[QueenB4]

Originally posted by White_King

It's not a smash it's a slight under performance
Not a total bomb a la Bionic though

[wehan6]

it's doing OK

definitely not a complete flop