[Jessie Mulay]

Originally posted by halcyonday

Chanel was too shocked about the missing Mommy body imo. It can't be her, but I agree. It has to be someone from the campus. I mean, the Red Devil attacked this previous queen of KKT.

Originally posted by Caesar

What texts are you guys talking about? during when Chanel #2 gets killed?

Originally posted by Repo

You can see it at 2:07 here, maybe the shot was cut from the show?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpoChDen9lc

EDIT: Looked at the scene, they have a big white space earlier when "I'm going to kill you" is sent then it reappears there later. So Ryan Murphy LITERALLY USED WHITE OUT to hide it. You only ever do that with a real clue.

them giving it away this early

Still praying it isn't her

[Retro]

This is a mess, and Ryan is getting so much **** from me if it's Chanel.

He's getting ten times more **** if he's hinted at it but it's NOT her.

[Repo]

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

them giving it away this early

Still praying it isn't her

The fact he literally whited out the text is what confirms it. You can tell Ryan realized what he did, tried to fix it, but somehow forget to finish the job

Originally posted by Retro

This is a mess, and Ryan is getting so much **** from me if it's Chanel.

He's getting ten times more **** if he's hinted at it but it's NOT her.

As said, I don't want Chanel to be the killer jsut... everything points to it.

[Caesar]

I rewatched a part of the show & when Chad / Chanel are having sexual intercoarse, Chad is like I'm gonna choke you or whatever and Chanel is like Chad theres a killer on the lose!!! That kinda threw me off a bit

[Retro]

Originally posted by Repo

As said, I don't want Chanel to be the killer jsut... everything points to it.

But with the possibility that it's also Wes , maybe it's reverse psychology and poor editing / mistakes working together to make it look hardcore like it's her.

[Jessie Mulay]

Let's hope that #2 just thought it was her. And it isn't really her.

[Repo]

Originally posted by Retro

But with the possibility that it's also Wes , maybe it's reverse psychology and poor editing / mistakes working together to make it look hardcore like it's her.

I'd say Chanel #5 is a strong candidate too. I'd LIKE it to be reverse psychology though, but I'm not sure Ryan is smart enough to do that. If you think bck to AHS: Asylum, Bloodyface ended up being.... the person with zero redherrings taht all the evidence pointed towards. And that's kinda just how this stuff works, since the showrunners/writers think they're being clever by not throwing in redherrings.

Tho as said, the only people we can 100% rule out are Pete/Cathy, both of whom the show has thrown TONS of suspicion on

[Jessie Mulay]

I don't know if we know yet but is the second season going to serve an AHS area where it's a different thing or will it be a continuation, or a continuation in the future etc

[Repo]

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

I don't know if we know yet but is the second season going to serve an AHS area where it's a different thing or will it be a continuation, or a continuation in the future etc

It's baasically a sequel. The four survivors will return, but all new location (Summer Camp), all new killer, all new story, etc.

This is also why it's critical we do NOT get a s****y set of survivors. Zayday is pretty given I think, and Chad looks really likely too. Grace/Pete seem probable, but they could be fakeouts. Wouldn't count on it tho.

[Retro]

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

I don't know if we know yet but is the second season going to serve an AHS area where it's a different thing or will it be a continuation, or a continuation in the future etc

It's another anthology series, so little connection will exist between seasons.

That's why only 3 or 4 characters will survive the season.

[Caesar]

I'm gonna be so pressed if Emma Roberts is not in the next season

[Retro]

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

Let's hope that #2 just thought it was her. And it isn't really her.

And that maybe - just maybe - Ryan intended to take it out because he thought that would cast suspicion in the wrong direction and simply epically failed at removing it.

[Jessie Mulay]

Originally posted by Repo

It's baasically a sequel. The four survivors will return, but all new location (Summer Camp), all new killer, all new story, etc.

This is also why it's critical we do NOT get a s****y set of survivors. Zayday is pretty given I think, and Chad looks really likely too. Grace/Pete seem probable, but they could be fakeouts. Wouldn't count on it tho.

Originally posted by Retro

It's another anthology series, so little connection will exist between seasons.

That's why only 3 or 4 characters will survive the season.

Oh yes, that's what I wanted

[Retro]

Originally posted by Caesar

I'm gonna be so pressed if Emma Roberts is not in the next season

Eh. I'm convinced she'll survive and be in the next one just because she's the lead actress. It's essentially her show.

[Repo]

Originally posted by Retro

And that maybe - just maybe - Ryan intended to take it out because he thought that would cast suspicion in the wrong direction and simply epically failed at removing it.

Who's ever heard of a showrunner removing a redherring for the not-killer tho? Like, how much of a logic fail would that be on Ryan's part

"Wow, this makes it seem like Chanel might be the killer when it's not Chanel! We can't have people suspect the wrong person!"

[Retro]

My bets are on Chanel, Zayday, Grace (ugh), and some random I don't care about surviving (I consider everyone else but Nick a random).

[Retro]

Originally posted by Repo

Who's ever heard of a showrunner removing a redherring for the not-killer tho? Like, how much of a logic fail would that be on Ryan's part

"Wow, this makes it seem like Chanel might be the killer when it's not Chanel! We can't have people suspect the wrong person!"

Well, he is an idiot, so let's not put it past him!

[halcyonday]

I kinda believe Repo with this text thing. One second it's not there, and then whoop, you can see it.

[Jessie Mulay]

Does this 4 people count non College students?

[Repo]

Originally posted by Retro

Well, he is an idiot, so let's not put it past him!

Him trying to remove it because he feels it's too obvious but forgetting to remove it from the trailers + the other shot is way more stupid and way more in with Ryan's inability to have any consistency tho

Originally posted by Jessie Mulay

Does this 4 people count non College students?

Yes. As said, Zayday seems 100% destined, and they seem to genuinely want to develop Chad (fourth billing, has redeeming qualities in the pilot, family showing up) so he's kinda likely. Grace/Pete seem destined but cooooould be fake outs.

Chanel is toast