Back to ATRL
This is
Classic ATRL
, an interactive archive of our original website.
Music News
Charts
Videos
Celebria
Base
The Lounge
Best Of
YTT
Games
TRL Archive
User Name
Remember Me
Password
Members who joined ATRL prior to 2017, sign in here.
Any changes made to your password do not sync.
Classic ATRL
>
The Lounge
>
Discussion: The American Horror Story Rate /// WINNER: SR. MARY EUNICE
Sign In
Discussion: The American Horror Story Rate /// WINNER: SR. MARY EUNICE
Page 28 of 44
<
First
< Prev
8
18
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
38
Next >
Last
>
Last Post
Actions
Tylerbv
Member Since: 3/26/2012
Posts: 37,592
Post #541
How is Hayden still in this?
FINALLY Ben Harmon is out. He sucked. I only gave Violet a 6? She deserved better.
Jamie Brewer is slaying this list. All 3 of her roles were top 50
Nan or Ma Petite for the win.
C/H/A/N/E/L
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
Post #542
Hayden was one of the best characters of Murder House. Third behind Moira & Vivien.
lostinparadise
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 6,144
Post #543
Ugh, some of the exits today were tragic.
Ryanicorn
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 25,476
Post #544
Quote:
Originally posted by
P!nk Forever
45
Dylan McDermott
as
Johnny Morgan (Asylum)
also portrayed by
Nolan Gross (as young Johnny Morgan)
Score
6.496
Highest/Lover:
10
(
x2
)
10 iforgiveyou
10 lostinparadise
9 Kyle.
8 Giliap
8 LadyLana
8 Superiore
7.8 Navyofbadgals
7.5 Repo
7 Haus_of_Will
7 keshaspearsxo
7 Lucas32
7 Ryanicorn
7 TheGreatestThing
6.6 Dragonfly
6.5 HausOfJustin
6 CREATIVEREBELLIO
6 Dark Poet
6 Spears_Stan
5 jacklovesyou1
5 P!nk Forever
5 Phenex
4 Brunette Ambition
4 Luigi
4 Tylerbv
Lowest/Hater:
1
(
x1
)
1 pxxxtrick
Side Note:
Personal Quote: My theory about actors is we're all walking milk cartons. Expirations dates everywhere.
Dylan is a 2nd time as Dr. Ben Harmon (Murder House) in this rate.
Quote:
Originally posted by
P!nk Forever
44
Neil Patrick Harris
as
Chester Creb (Freak Show)
Score
6.500
Highest/Lover:
9.8
(
x1
)
9.8 lostinparadise
9.2 Dragonfly
9 Ryanicorn
9 Repo
8 Superiore
8 Haus_of_Will
8 Tylerbv
8 iforgiveyou
8 Lucas32
8 Navyofbadgals
8 Brunette Ambition
8 Spears_Stan
7 Kyle.
7 Phenex
6.5 Giliap
6 CREATIVEREBELLIO
6 keshaspearsxo
6 pxxxtrick
6 Dark Poet
6 LadyLana
4 P!nk Forever
3 HausOfJustin
2 jacklovesyou1
Lowest/Hater:
1
(
x2
)
1 TheGreatestThing
1 Luigi
Side Note:
He has English, Scottish, and German ancestry.
NOOOOO
At least we got to see his cakes
Quote:
Originally posted by
P!nk Forever
42
Gabourey Sidibe
as
Queenie (Coven)
Score
6.716
Highest/Lover:
10
(
x2
)
10 lostinparadise
10 Ryanicorn
9 pxxxtrick
8.5 HausOfJustin
8.5 iforgiveyou
8 CREATIVEREBELLIO
8 Lucas32
8 P!nk Forever
8 Phenex
8 Tylerbv
7.5 Giliap
7.4 Dragonfly
7 Dark Poet
7 keshaspearsxo
7 Kyle.
7 Navyofbadgals
6 Brunette Ambition
6 Haus_of_Will
6 LadyLana
6 Spears_Stan
5 Superiore
5 TheGreatestThing
3 jacklovesyou1
Lowest/Hater:
1
(
x2
)
1 Luigi
1 Repo
Side Note:
Her father is from Senegal. Her mother is African-American, and is originally from Georgia.
Gabourey's Chart Positions:
95. Regina Ross (Freak Show)
42. Queenie (Coven)
Are you ****ing kidding me
Quote:
Originally posted by
Tylerbv
I love Marjorie
How the **** is Ben Harmon still in this? He was ****ing annoying as ****.
Quote:
Originally posted by
P!nk Forever
40
Dylan McDermott
as
Dr. Ben Harmon (Murder House)
Score
6.784
Highest/Lover:
9.5
(
x1
)
9.5 iforgiveyou
9 Dark Poet
9 lostinparadise
9 Lucas32
8.5 Giliap
8.3 Navyofbadgals
8 HausOfJustin
8 Kyle.
8 LadyLana
8 pxxxtrick
7.5 P!nk Forever
7 Brunette Ambition
7 Haus_of_Will
7 Repo
7 Superiore
6 jacklovesyou1
6 Spears_Stan
6 TheGreatestThing
5.8 Dragonfly
5 CREATIVEREBELLIO
5 Luigi
5 Phenex
5 Ryanicorn
3 keshaspearsxo
Lowest/Hater:
2
(
x1
)
2 Tylerbv
Side Note:
McDermott told an interviewer in 1987 that Bogart, Brando, Nicholson, and De Niro were his acting role models.
Dylan's Chart Positions:
45. Johnny Morgan (Asylum)
40. Dr. Ben Harmon (Murder House)
Quote:
Originally posted by
P!nk Forever
37
Taissa Farmiga
as
Violet Harmon (Murder House)
Score
6.906
Highest/Lover:
10
(
x3
)
10 lostinparadise
10 pxxxtrick
10 Ryanicorn
9.5 Giliap
9.2 Dragonfly
9 HausOfJustin
9 Kyle.
9 Superiore
9 TheGreatestThing
8 jacklovesyou1
8 LadyLana
7 Dark Poet
7 Lucas32
7 Navyofbadgals
7 P!nk Forever
7 Spears_Stan
6 Brunette Ambition
6 CREATIVEREBELLIO
6 keshaspearsxo
6 Phenex
6 Tylerbv
3 iforgiveyou
2 Haus_of_Will
Lowest/Hater:
1
(
x2
)
1 Luigi
1 Repo
Side Note:
She can play the guitar, cook, and has mastered the art of making origami cranes.
Taissa's Chart Positions:
59. Zoe Benson (Coven)
37. Violet Harmon (Murder House)
ARE YOU ****ING KIDDING ME
Quote:
Originally posted by
lostinparadise
Ugh, some of the exits today were tragic.
!!!!!!!!!!
CREATIVEREBELLION
Member Since: 4/4/2014
Posts: 1,241
Post #545
Hayden was iconic i don't know why y'all playing with her
Dragonfly
Member Since: 8/19/2013
Posts: 6,141
Post #546
Cordelia out??!!! Have some respect for your Supreme
She plucked her own eyes out for gods sake
________________________
Bye Ben Harmon
Superiore
Member Since: 10/2/2011
Posts: 43,174
Post #547
Literally a saint
Haus_of_Will
Member Since: 8/20/2011
Posts: 8,848
Post #548
Am not pressed by any of the eliminations so far except for the Mexican.
Spears_Stan
Member Since: 8/18/2013
Posts: 212
Post #549
yasss at gloria still being in
P!nk Forever
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 5,531
Thread Starter
|
Post #550
The next 5 eliminations will be posted in less than an hour.
C/H/A/N/E/L
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
Post #551
Ryan, I love you, but please stop quoting those massive posts all at once. Make a reaction post without quoting cuz, ch...
P!nk Forever
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 5,531
Thread Starter
|
Post #552
Our first position belongs to a major Asylum character!
Haus_of_Will
Member Since: 8/20/2011
Posts: 8,848
Post #553
It's Shelley.
P!nk Forever
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 5,531
Thread Starter
|
Post #554
35
Joseph Fiennes
as
Monsignor Timothy Howard (Asylum)
Score
7.056
Highest/Lover:
9.9
(
x1
)
9.9 lostinparadise
9.2 Dragonfly
9 Spears_Stan
8.8 Navyofbadgals
8 Haus_of_Will
8 iforgiveyou
8 Lucas32
8 pxxxtrick
8 Ryanicorn
7 Brunette Ambition
7 CREATIVEREBELLIO
7 Dark Poet
7 Kyle.
7 Luigi
7 Repo
7 Superiore
7 TheGreatestThing
7 Tylerbv
6.5 Giliap
6 HausOfJustin
6 keshaspearsxo
6 P!nk Forever
6 Phenex
4 jacklovesyou1
Lowest/Hater:
2
(
x1
)
2 LadyLana
Side Note:
Greatly skilled at swimming, horse riding, tennis and rock-climbing.
C/H/A/N/E/L
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
Post #555
Bye
P!nk Forever
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 5,531
Thread Starter
|
Post #556
Next one coming is a total bitch!
Navyofbadgals
Member Since: 8/17/2013
Posts: 15,103
Post #557
Ready for madisons exit
C/H/A/N/E/L
ATRL Contributor
Member Since: 5/28/2011
Posts: 39,615
Post #558
If it's Madison...
P!nk Forever
Member Since: 9/1/2013
Posts: 5,531
Thread Starter
|
Post #559
34
Kate Mara
as
Hayden McClaine (Murder House)
Score
7.256
Highest/Lover:
10
(
x2
)
10 CREATIVEREBELLIO
10 lostinparadise
9 Giliap
9 iforgiveyou
9 Phenex
9 Repo
9 Spears_Stan
9 TheGreatestThing
8.4 Dragonfly
8 Haus_of_Will
8 Lucas32
8 Navyofbadgals
8 pxxxtrick
8 Ryanicorn
8 Superiore
7 Dark Poet
7 keshaspearsxo
7 P!nk Forever
6 Brunette Ambition
5 HausOfJustin
5 Kyle.
5 LadyLana
3 jacklovesyou1
3 Luigi
Lowest/Hater:
2
(
x1
)
2 Tylerbv
Side Note:
Her younger sister Rooney (real name: Patricia) is also an actress.
Haus_of_Will
Member Since: 8/20/2011
Posts: 8,848
Post #560
Hayden basically carried like a third of the first season.
Page 28 of 44
<
First
< Prev
8
18
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
38
Next >
Last
>
Actions for this Thread
Print this Thread
"Absolute TRL" 1999-2006; "Popfusion" 2006-2007; "ATRL" 2007-present
Nan or Ma Petite for the win.
At least we got to see his cakes 
