Katy Perry: 7. Her songs are very sugary, which can be a good or a bad thing. I don't know how much room she has left to grow. She could make a more personal album but I just don't know. The LFN remix hurt her score for me. She also plays it very safe. She hasn't really offered anything new to the table yet.
Mariah Carey: 2. This would've been a one pre-MOAPA, but her downfall is making her image be someone of half her age.
Justin Timberlake: 3. He holds his own ground & maintains individuality.
Keri Hilson: 8. I like her music but her music is not the most personal or deep. Her image can also be tacky at times (points off for NBA shoot in pink restrooms
). She has a terrible image even though she gets a lot of undeserved hate IMO. Her voice talent is usually disguised by how she handles herself, which is basically.
Britney Spears: 8. She lacks respect. Lip-synching is a huge negative, I can't stand it. She lacks range. She is not respected for her vocals. She can't really dance like she used to, & although I really enjoy Femme Fatale, her current music offers nothing new to the table. She is losing her individuality. I don't mean to sound like a hater.
Christina Aguilera: 4. Her greatness weakness is trying too hard to be different. And she tries to hard to belt, & it strains her vocals in live performances.
Avril Lavigne 5. She gets undeserved hate for sure. She is very talented. But her image is childish & makes her look more basic than she really is. She needs to mature her wardrobe. And her pop tunes that are released as singles & define her albums are terrible & weak & make her look more basic than anyone else.