Demi didn't impress me very much. Most of her comments seemed like incoherent rambling filled with "umm, I think you have a good voice but maybe you need umm". Unlike Britney though, she definitely engaged in conversation with the judges and contestants.
Glad Britney got her personality back and looks happy for once
If you read his full comment though he says she's like "stuck in her lonely world" or something because she has no connection with the judges and the contestants.
Demi really surprised me as a judge. I actually thought she gave the best constructive criticism of anyone, and she wasn’t afraid to get negative when she needed to.
I looked at the TWOP link, and it annoys me how easily they discount Demi. Everyone does. And it doesn't take a genius to see that having both Britney and Demi isn't redundant.
I really want Demi to prove all the naysayers wrong. I know she has what it takes to make a great judge. Plus, being a good judge would only be a career boost. I want a Cheryl Cole thing to happen. Demi's true breakout.
someone in that forum liked her as a judge
