They are saying quality!!11 as if this was a Lana case where she stopped making commercial music to become more accclaimed ()
I know for sure Joanne will be a critical flop too
I don't think it will. Even Glory is in the 70s. So it's expected for Gaga to at least score within the mid 70s. Especially considering the collaborations she was involved in. She claimed that PI isn't a true indicator of the album so anything can happen as far as sound/quality wise.