[Yves]

Another ballad? That will flop hard. Y'all forgot about Adele's When We Were Young so quickly.

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Torturo

HDD: Building (89%)
SPS
15 LADY GAGA JOANNE 13,883
PURE
13 LADY GAGA JOANNE 11,197

so 11k garantueed. will probably reach 15k pure and ~25k SPS

Oh also with this taken into account, Joanne crossed 300k Pure Sales in US this week for sure

[Nikko]

MR is relatable, Joanne isn't. Don't play yourselves.

[monster_enriquer]

Originally posted by Torturo

HDD: Building (89%)
SPS
15 LADY GAGA JOANNE 13,883
PURE
13 LADY GAGA JOANNE 11,197

so 11k garantueed. will probably reach 15k pure and ~25k SPS

This is good na?

[Badgalbriel]

Joanne ain't becoming a single. What the hell are you all thinking!?
For Next single she will probably want A-No

[Rusty]

Just saw an ad for Queen on Alan Carr tonight. It's before her Westfield set I think, so they might show that MR performance.

[HonourableVomit]

Originally posted by Nikko

MR is relatable, Joanne isn't. Don't play yourselves.

Like death isn't relateable?

[Reinvention]

"Joanne" would be her worst ever single, swiftly taking "Perfect Illusion"s crown tbh.

Honestly - the only stab she has left is the cute fun radio bop "Dancing in Godcles". Otherwise... welp!

[Badgalbriel]

Originally posted by HonourableVomit

Like death isn't relateable?

Sis, no one will buy a song named Joanne and feel the connection with it when the song is about some dead aunt.
How is that not clear?

[HAPPI•LIL•PILL]

I like "Joanne"...but it's too bland to be a single. They should remix it.

[Rusty]

The fact that 2010 or even 2011Ga could have smashed with DH but it'd probably go nowhere today

GOOD THING I KNOW WHAT I'M WORTH!

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Badgalbriel

Sis, no one will buy a song named Joanne and feel the connection with it when the song is about some dead aunt.
How is that not clear?

She should make like 50 versions with the most popular names in US or the world

[Gazing Ball]

Diamond Heart is a lot like Marry The Night I think. And we know how that went...

[Opium]

Originally posted by Yves

Another ballad? That will flop hard. Y'all forgot about Adele's When We Were Young so quickly.

yeah, ballad after ballad isn't the best idea besides that, Miley tried it too with Adore You after Wrecking Ball and flopped

[Torturo]

Originally posted by Opium

yeah, ballad after ballad isn't the best idea besides that, Miley tried it too with Adore You after Wrecking Ball and flopped

adele tried it with her discography and it worked

[Opium]

Originally posted by Torturo

adele tried it with her discography and it worked

well, Gaga and Adele are different type of artists

[Opium]

honestly, I hope the upcoming singles will be smth like this : John Wayne (around the Superbowl), Dancin' In Circles (a bit before summer), Sinner's Prayer (for autumn) and maybe Joanne (close to winter)

[vince_martin88]

Come to Mama, Sinner's Prayer, Million Reasons, Dancin' in Circles and Diamond Heart are top 5

[JessLM]

Originally posted by vince_martin88

Come to Mama, Sinner's Prayer, Million Reasons, Dancin' in Circles and Diamond Heart are top 5

I'd replace MR with AD but not mad at this tea.

[Ramos]

Joanne is #6 in Mexico for the 2nd week, it debuted #1 so this is a good decline for 2nd week.

Mexican charts are like a month behind and they are just announcing the Oct 28th - Nov 3rd tracking week.