[Superiore]

Same goes for me.

I've been writing but now I think no one sees it!

[Retro]

I'm late I'm sorry don't hurt me bye and if I ranked u last I still love u

[Cupid]

Most Dedicated Monster (Won)

Someone snatch ha title, she can't even dedicate haself to the deadline.

[Scorpio]

Episode 4 - Elimination Ceremony: Judges Comments 1

First of all you are going to get the comments that each judge made for your entries.
After that you are going to get the results. Good luck.

FOR YOUR INFORMATION:

I used some of my hit gifs in my comments to bless you all.

Clearly you need some blessing in your lives.

---

Superiore

Originally posted by Kitt

A lessor version and reminiscent of



Bonus points though because I feel like this I've seen this before the challenge therefore a slight local smash??

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

It's a decent gif with some potential, but I don't see it really being as versatile as some other entries. I feel as though your examples in particular could have been stronger. However, it's a great start - GIF challenges have never been my strong suit and it's better than I could have done!

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

For starters, why would anybody want to gif him? Secondly, the gif is too slow, it slows down right at the end its annoying. Thirdly, it only matches with one example you used, the first one. It doesn't express sadness, shade or anything else apart from if you wanted to wave and point yourself out in a post. Overall, a disappointment, I don't see this getting much use unless it was in an ironic fashion.

Originally posted by DOMINO

It’s not necessarily bad. It’s not good either, though. Its usage is very limited and, that shouldn’t even be a factor, but I’m kind of over the Grande family.

Rider

Originally posted by Kitt

Ever since someone pointed out that she looks old in this gif I can't stop noticing that.

Bonus points because I feel like this I've seen this before the challenge, therefore a local smash??? I had to reverse image search it to be sure and ran across EuphorianSea using it on another forum kii. I think you have an inner smash gif maker budding in you.

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

I like the gif - I could see it being used. The examples started off weak but got a bit stronger - you just have to find the right niche for the gif, so to speak.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

Yes this gif is semi-starting to take off. I actually really like it, it is very similar to the standard "bopping" gifs we get. They usually get popular for a few weeks then disappear. There's something about her smile and hairflick which sets it apart from regular bopping gifs though. There's something almost shady behind it. I can see this being a hit, albeit for a few weeks, well done!

Originally posted by DOMINO

This is really good. I can imagine using it in basically every occasion plus it’s Fergie so a bonus for that.

EuphorianSea

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

I felt that you needed stronger examples, primarily. The gif is good.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

I like the idea behind the gif, ratchet person getting all angry up on the camera so you can clock peoples posts etc. Except the camera is really shaky and the gif is too slow/long. I feel like we already have better gifs we can use to signify this, iHype uses a lot of them. Take from that what you will.

Originally posted by DOMINO

What is dis?

darkhorse

Originally posted by Kitt

The gif is mediocore to me, but points for creating a flop thread to stimulate it's usage Bold for someone who literally just came out of the blue on this site and game.

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

Pretty damn good, not much to say.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

I'm disappointed. The first part of the gif gave me such hope, it looked like it was about to be iconic. But then she stands up and the camera just disappears and goes crazy. From the gif alone it just leaves me annoyed because I want to see what happens next. It's not awful, just rather average.

Originally posted by DOMINO

Okay I don’t know what it is but this is by far my favorite gif of the bunch. I love these type of gifs and that nice and clean layout. Slé. It is not perfect though, just my favorite.

coolcristobal

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

I feel that the place of this gif is more or less occupied by better options, but your examples helped strengthen your entry. Good work on that.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

Is that Bill Cosby? Lol. At first I was like okay this gif is alright I guess, but after seeing the examples it made me like it a lot more. I can see this having a lot of hit potential.

Originally posted by DOMINO

Not bad. I can see myself using it. Like when I see you guys in real life or something.

Serendipity

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

Good work. You did not disappoint - it's not perfect but nobody is and it's useful and I liked your examples.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

Oh my Kylie, I can't describe how much this irritates me. There is nothing fun about bad road safety kids. As a driver and someone who really enjoys driving, this ****ing guy needs to get mowed down. If that was me i'd literally get out and clock him in his annoying little face the annoying piece of garbage. I also see no use for this gif at all, it doesn't fit in any of those examples.

Originally posted by DOMINO

Not with those tacky ass colors Serena. Besides, that gif just leaves me questioning what exactly it represents. Why would I use it? Hm.. Questions over questions - but I need an answer.

Stay tuned.

[Allstar]

W8ing

[Retro]

Originally posted by Cupid

Someone snatch ha title, she can't even dedicate haself to the deadline.

Hu r u

[Scorpio]

Episode 4 - Elimination Ceremony: Judges Comments 2

---

FunkyDinevo

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

The shade. The LaLingo. I live.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

I feel like i've seen this before, it's identical to basically every gif you use. It has a lot of hit potential, but you've played it safe.

Originally posted by DOMINO

I can definitely see myself using it. Partly because I loved that show and partly because that’s exactly how I looked when you sent in your entry late.

Element

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

Relatively useful and versatile, and humerous to boot! Not bad at all.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

Okay I gotta admit I laughed for like 30 seconds at this... It has so much potential, it literally defines messy posts.

Originally posted by DOMINO

This ain’t happening, Element. And if it does then congratulations. You should have waited with your superior gif which smashes nations. I am disappointed.

Capital B

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

Just make it a little smaller.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

Girl no sorry, I'm not here for you ripping off (certain pop girl'ing) an already hit gif. It has slight potential but I don't like the coloring it looks off and it's not as good as the one you took "inspiration" from.

Originally posted by DOMINO

Mess this is just the reverse version of my hit Suprisée gif. I see you B.

Allstar

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

I've virtually given up on comments at this point but ****, this is perfect. The examples are perfect. You're per- whoops, nope, that sounds creepy, enjoy your ten.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

I like that you took a different approach to this round, we've seen a lot of "official" gifs on here, like that news lady who shuffles her papers etc. I just don't feel like this is shady or memorable/special enough to catch on. Rather average actually.

Originally posted by DOMINO

It has potential but clearly no one was here for it in the Les ATRLers thread. But it does have potential. Promote it and you’re good.

Melvin

Originally posted by Kitt

- Only had time for a couple of comments. -

Originally posted by Matty

Originally posted by Retro

I feel as though the GIF is a little LQ and hectic, and has a somewhat niche connotation (even your first two examples were tied to police issues these days). It could be more versatile if you know what I mean.

Originally posted by H-I-M

He only did the ranking and gave you scores.

Originally posted by Cupid

The examples were great and I loved the edit lol but honestly the gif is so small and dark its hard to tell exactly whats going on. I think the actual scene in the gif is great but I don't think it's usable enough on ATRL or translates well into a gif.

Originally posted by DOMINO

Yes, I can use this. But don’t you ever play with me like that Melvin. You know exactly what happens to my heart when you do that.

Prismatic

Originally posted by DOMINO

GERL BYE

Stay tuned.

[darkhorse]

Well... let's see the scores.

[Retro]

I don't at all like that some of my comments clash with the trend of the other judges THIS IS NOT OKAY.

[Superiore]

You better DRAG me, especially Cupid!

[Rider]

Hmmmmm
I'm perched

[Superiore]

The Prismatic comment

[Allstar]

I've got nothing but LOVE for Retro

[Cupid]

I had no idea Prismatic didn't even submit, after I saved her last round too. Ungrateful smh.

[Superiore]

Originally posted by Cupid

I had no idea Prismatic didn't even submit, after I saved her last round too. Ungrateful smh.

[Melvin]

Everyone went ghost.

[Rider]

Maybe next page

[Retro]

Someone just throw the results out there so I can feel bad if I was the reason someone was booted

[Scorpio]

Well I ain't posting the results on this page so you better move with the quickness.

[Retro]

Bitch not on a new page you don't