[Superiore]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

What would you prefer?

How about The Boss, Diana Ross?

I'm not really into them so it would be kinda awkward to host a rate about someone I don't know much about.

No one from the newer generations?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Himeros

I'm not really into them so it would be kinda awkward to host a rate about someone I don't know much about.

No one from the newer generations?

Celine has never been done? In terms of singles that is.

[Superiore]

Celine would be interesting, even if most of ATRL kinda dislikes her!

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Which Greatest Hits would you use for all of them?

Just use Ultimate Kylie, Celebration & Number Ones.

[MP2K]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

We need more singles rates up.

After Michael and Ciara are done, who's next y'all?

The Beatles and Diana Ross?
Celine Dion and Prince?
Beyoncé and Eminem?

[Ozzy8923]

I wanna do a self-titled albums rate.

I thought about which ones I'd include and I'd do the following:
Madonna
Britney / Britney Jean
BEYONCE
Robyn
Mariah Carey
Christina Aguilera
Kylie Minogue
J. Lo
Taylor Swift
Ciara

Decided to not include Celine, Barbra, Cher, Shania, Aaliyah, Ashanti, N Sync, The Backstreet Boys, Kate Bush, Evanescence, Demi, Jennifer Hudson, Elton John, the Jonas Brothers, KISS, etc because ATRL simply doesn't care much about them so it'd be pointless. I included mostly people with a reasonably sized ATRL fan base.

Plus, 11 albums should be more than enough.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

I wanna do a self-titled albums rate.

I thought about which ones I'd include and I'd do the following:
Madonna
Britney / Britney Jean
BEYONCE
Robyn
Mariah Carey
Christina Aguilera
Kylie Minogue
J. Lo
Taylor Swift
Ciara

Kylie has 2 (technically 3) self-titled albums

And wasn't there meant to be a self-titled debut rate for Kylie, Mimi, Madonna etc.?

[@michael]

Originally posted by Subomie

And wasn't there meant to be a self-titled debut rate for Kylie, Mimi, Madonna etc.?

That's been on hold for a while now http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=197067

[Ozzy8923]

Originally posted by Subomie

Kylie has 2 (technically 3) self-titled albums

And wasn't there meant to be a self-titled debut rate for Kylie, Mimi, Madonna etc.?

I know, but Impossible Princess is the actual name of one of them and the other is KM94, correct? So I'll just do the one with the actual full name as its title.

As for the other rate you're referring to, mine isn't about debut albums and that rate has been inactive since March and the thread is closed, so that should make for plenty of availability for mine.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by @michael

That's been on hold for a while now http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=197067

omg, it would be so good tho

[Ace Reject]

Since that rate was a FLOP, y'all can take it over if you want!

[BlueGangsta]

Originally posted by MP2K

The Beatles and Diana Ross?
Celine Dion and Prince?
Beyoncé and Eminem?

prince yesssss

[Blueberry Mary]

Originally posted by @michael

That's been on hold for a while now http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=197067

I'd participate. Maybe best to include Janet's '93 self-titled instead of her first one

[Toysoldier99]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Which Greatest Hits would you use for all of them?

Janet- The Best = 36 songs
Madonna- Celebration= 36 songs
Kylie Minogue- Ultimate Kylie- 34

So in total 106 songs. Is that maybe too much?

[Ace Reject]

Originally posted by Toysoldier99

Janet- The Best = 36 songs
Madonna- Celebration= 36 songs
Kylie Minogue- Ultimate Kylie- 34

So in total 106 songs. Is that maybe too much?

Surprising that you're doing those three, and not Immaculate Collection/GH Vol 1/Design of a Decade. Much shorter, and all of their best hits.

[Subomie]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Since that rate was a FLOP, y'all can take it over if you want!

It does sound like a great rate, but I really wonder if people would be here for it now?

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Surprising that you're doing those three, and not Immaculate Collection/GH Vol 1/Design of a Decade. Much shorter, and all of their best hits.

Kylie would be destroyed

[Toysoldier99]

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Surprising that you're doing those three, and not Immaculate Collection/GH Vol 1/Design of a Decade. Much shorter, and all of their best hits.

I thought it would be more interesting that way

[conseeded]

Originally posted by Ozzy8923

I wanna do a self-titled albums rate.

I thought about which ones I'd include and I'd do the following:
Madonna
Britney / Britney Jean
BEYONCE
Robyn
Mariah Carey
Christina Aguilera
Kylie Minogue
J. Lo
Taylor Swift
Ciara

C'mon Ace

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Subomie

It does sound like a great rate, but I really wonder if people would be here for it now?

I still have my scores! As Kylie once said, let's get to it.

[supaspaz]

Honestly, the pop girl rates (millennials, seniors and Disney divisions) might need a hiatus. We've done so many that we're starting to repeat ourselves. Meanwhile there are so many other great ideas that have been paid dust.