[JeremyALD]

Originally posted by DejaVu

I hadn't realized some of our fellow Kelly fans are complete trash. Some of the arguments for DBAGAI are just cringe-worthy. Arrogant and ignorant. I'm not gonna say much more about the DBAGAI-mess, but it is just that. A mess. Looks like the label agreed since it was demoted to a bonus track


So I was thinking how much better it would've been if, instead of rerecording Mr Know It All as a country song, why didn't they do it to "The War Is Over"? TWIO won't do well on pop, but I can imagine it being HUGE on country radio with the right sound. Plus that would make it elligible for the Grammys and country music award shows.

Anyone object to that single order? MKIA > WDKY > DS > TWIO > IFY

I don't think they would release two ballads in a row and I really think Let Me Down should be given a shot. It is one of the catchiest songs on the album and one that doesn't repeat itself 3000 times (IFY).

The better question is why did they make a country version if they weren't going to bother releasing it. I honestly think that mix could of gone top 10 on country after DYWS.

And really Chris? What do you have against that song?

[JClarkSTAN]

Originally posted by DejaVu

I hadn't realized some of our fellow Kelly fans are complete trash. Some of the arguments for DBAGAI are just cringe-worthy. Arrogant and ignorant. I'm not gonna say much more about the DBAGAI-mess, but it is just that. A mess. Looks like the label agreed since it was demoted to a bonus track

So I was thinking how much better it would've been if, instead of rerecording Mr Know It All as a country song, why didn't they do it to "The War Is Over"? TWIO won't do well on pop, but I can imagine it being HUGE on country radio with the right sound. Plus that would make it elligible for the Grammys and country music award shows.

<3

I actually agree with you. I loveeeeee TWIO. Its my favorite on the album. It tells such a great story and deserves to be a single. Making it more country and releasing it there would've been amazing.

[esteee12]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Missing y'all !!

Finally you're back! Missing you too!

[esteee12]

Originally posted by DejaVu

I hadn't realized some of our fellow Kelly fans are complete trash. Some of the arguments for DBAGAI are just cringe-worthy. Arrogant and ignorant. I'm not gonna say much more about the DBAGAI-mess, but it is just that. A mess. Looks like the label agreed since it was demoted to a bonus track

So I was thinking how much better it would've been if, instead of rerecording Mr Know It All as a country song, why didn't they do it to "The War Is Over"? TWIO won't do well on pop, but I can imagine it being HUGE on country radio with the right sound. Plus that would make it elligible for the Grammys and country music award shows.



Kelly can fit in with anyone. Vocal Chameleon

If she did a duets album, who would you want on it? For Me..

Justin Timberlake
Adele
Amy Lee
Kris Allen
Coldplay
Tony Bennett
Mariah Carey
P!nk
Bruno Mars
Colbie Caillat
Daughtry
Tamyra Gray (again!)



I love this.

Hey, do yall remember before the albums release Kelly had her friends tweet their favorite songs? Maybe that can also give us insight on potential singles/order?

It was...

Stronger - Kelly tweeted it.
You Love Me - Kelly tweeted it as her favorite, so I think we can ignore it.
Dark Side - Kelly tweeted it again
The War Is Over - Blake Shelton
I Forgive You - Ellen

Anyone object to that single order? MKIA > WDKY > DS > TWIO > IFY

Justin Timberlake
Adele
Amy Lee
Kris Allen
Coldplay
Tony Bennett
Mariah Carey
P!nk
Bruno Mars
Colbie Caillat
Daughtry
Tamyra Gray (again!)

The ones bolded are the artists i want kelly to do a duet with. Hopefully pink will be up for it! I saw a thread here that she may be releasing a new album this year! Hopefully it will feature kelly! can't wait for them to do magic in the music studio if this happens!

[JClarkSTAN]

Well Kelly said herself that she wants to duet with Bruno. I wish he hopped on a Mr. Know It All remix. It would've slayed.

[JeremyALD]

We have had like 3 duets in Kelly's entire career.

Let's hope we get queen Kara as another surprise in album 6

[vonno]

Im guilty of this

[[Bask]]

Originally posted by JeremyALD

We have had like 3 duets in Kelly's entire career.

Let's hope we get queen Kara as another surprise in album 6

I think Kelly has 4 duet songs

You Thought Wrong
Timeless
Because Of You
Dont You Wanna Stay

[dhilamilan1899]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Missing y'all !!

Hi, kev... wassup?

[dhilamilan1899]

Originally posted by DejaVu

I hadn't realized some of our fellow Kelly fans are complete trash. Some of the arguments for DBAGAI are just cringe-worthy. Arrogant and ignorant. I'm not gonna say much more about the DBAGAI-mess, but it is just that. A mess. Looks like the label agreed since it was demoted to a bonus track

So I was thinking how much better it would've been if, instead of rerecording Mr Know It All as a country song, why didn't they do it to "The War Is Over"? TWIO won't do well on pop, but I can imagine it being HUGE on country radio with the right sound. Plus that would make it elligible for the Grammys and country music award shows.



Kelly can fit in with anyone. Vocal Chameleon

If she did a duets album, who would you want on it? For Me..

Justin Timberlake
Adele
Amy Lee
Kris Allen
Coldplay
Tony Bennett
Mariah Carey
P!nk
Bruno Mars
Colbie Caillat
Daughtry
Tamyra Gray (again!)



I love this.

Hey, do yall remember before the albums release Kelly had her friends tweet their favorite songs? Maybe that can also give us insight on potential singles/order?

It was...

Stronger - Kelly tweeted it.
You Love Me - Kelly tweeted it as her favorite, so I think we can ignore it.
Dark Side - Kelly tweeted it again
The War Is Over - Blake Shelton
I Forgive You - Ellen

Anyone object to that single order? MKIA > WDKY > DS > TWIO > IFY

This!!!!

[tell_me_a_lie]

Originally posted by gareth_

If this is true why is it not a thread? Our gurls making billboard history!

Make one, boo.

[supertiffany]

Originally posted by gareth_

If this is true why is it not a thread? Our gurls making billboard history!

idk what are the other charts anyway?

[mandym]

All I can say is that I don't feel offended by DBAGAI and never did, but I can see why others could feel this way. Wasn't a good comparison.

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by gareth_

If this is true why is it not a thread? Our gurls making billboard history!

I wanna know who tweeted this though. It was probably a fan because this isn't really a "record" considering Billboard doesn't have a chart titled "HAC" and "AC".

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by [Bask]

I think Kelly has 4 duet songs

You Thought Wrong
Timeless
Because Of You
Dont You Wanna Stay

The Sun Will Rise

and any of the From Justin to Kelly duets.


What are some of her live duets?
Fast Car w/ Daughtry
Bring Me Some Water w/ Melissa Etheridge
Don't You Wanna Stay w/ Blake Shelton
What Hurts The Most w/ Rascal Flatts
Up To The Mountain w/ Jeff Beck
Amame w/ Alexandre Pires
etc

[Maybe]

[tell_me_a_lie]

Originally posted by Maybe

The verses sounded like My Heart Will Go On by Celine.

He tried but still

[HotDecember]

Originally posted by DejaVu

I wanna know who tweeted this though. It was probably a fan because this isn't really a "record" considering Billboard doesn't have a chart titled "HAC" and "AC".

btw, this is technically it's 17th week since it debuted on the Hot 100.

They're Adult Pop Songs and Adult Contemporary Chart

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by gareth_

Interesting iTunes figures, out of all her PAST singles, this is there current chart position...

Breakaway #556
Since U Been Gone #636
Already Gone #827
Because Of You#910
My Life Would Suck Without You #920

Why is Breakaway so high? I never realized it was so huge

Breakaways been consistently higher than SUBG for weeks now.

last week sales were...

02/25/12 Kelly Clarkson, Breakaway (6305, +35%, 1,430,542 total)
02/25/12 Kelly Clarkson, Already Gone (5,599, +73%, 1,705,952 total)
02/25/12 Kelly Clarkson, Since U Been Gone (5,400, +74%, 2,221,644 total)

[DejaVu]

Originally posted by gareth_

Thats crazy, is there any reason why? I would of assumed SUBG would be selling more just because its considered her signature hit. Anyway its good to see other Kelly songs getting recognition. And damn at Already Gone, really was a huge hit

I'm not sure why. It was her 2nd pop #1 and the title track to one of the biggest albums of the decade. Maybe if digital sales kicked in a tiny bit earlier, it would've competed against SUBG as her biggest hit in the US? I'm really not sure.

Already Gone is her 3rd best selling [solo] song (until Stronger passes it) Meanwhile, Don't You Wanna Stay should pass 2 million in 2-3 weeks.

Kelly Clarkson, Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You) (250,000,-4%, 1.493 million)
Jason Aldean/Kelly Clarkson, Don't You Wanna Stay (30,000, +47%, 1.955 million)
Kelly Clarkson, Mr. Know It All (25,000, -12%, 1.3 million)

Kelly Clarkson, Stronger (29,000 weekly, -7%, 597,000 total) (#13 Billboard 200)