NOBODY in the GP remembers ST songs sis. they bombed at radio in the first place. "Dance With You" "Get Me Bodied" and "Ego" too much.
The remembered Beyonce songs are CIL, SL and the DC catalog. Anything else is a desperate reach.
If I Were a Boy, Irreplaceable and Halo are literally radio staples.
Naughty Girl and Baby Boy are also still played a lot.
Give it up beyhive, this aint Rihanna or Katy Perry or whoever Beyonce is indeed bigger than!
When it comes to Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Madonna and dare I say even Celine Dion... Beyonce has so many things to achieve in order to be in the their league, let alone to surpass them!
Give it up beyhive, this aint Rihanna or Katy Perry or whoever Beyonce is indeed bigger than!
When it comes to Mariah Carey, Whitney Houston, Madonna and dare I say even Celine Dion... Beyonce has so many things to achieve in order to be in the their league, let alone to surpass them!
i can't at the Beyhive thinking all of her singles are remembered global classics.
I mean there are successful songs and then there are the legendary hits.
In my opinion the Beatles have the most classics with like 6-7 songs. Our main diva legends probably have 3-5 of such. If all those songs were timeless evergreens - as the Beyhive claims - then all successful singles must be alltime classics, but that's impossible bc we would drown in alltime classics and radio mostly play the same ole classic tunes constantly.
For Mariah I would say that those are her most important and remembered classics:
- Without You
- All I want for Christmas Is You
- Hero
For Whitney they are:
- I will always love you
- I wanna dance with somebody
- Greatest Love of all
both have several bubbling under hits - which are classics in certain regions.
Beyoncé probably has:
- Crazy in Love
- Single Ladies
Sales only play a minimum role in determining alltime evergreens. Its the impact that needs to be measured.
Madonna probably has:
- Vogue
- Like a Prayer
- Like a Virgin
- Live to Tell
- Papa don't Preach
+ some bubbling under hits...especially Music and Frozen
But I don't know anyone who has got 10 or more alltime evergreens.
If we're really being objective here, Beyoncé is more successful than both (has earned more money) and she is far more acclaimed. Mimi, Whitney, and Celine are Britney/Gaga/Katy level when it comes to acclaim. Even Rihanna is above them in that.
If we're really being objective here, Beyoncé is more successful than both (has earned more money) and she is far more acclaimed. Mimi, Whitney, and Celine are Britney/Gaga/Katy level when it comes to acclaim. Even Rihanna is above them in that.
If we're really being objective here, Beyoncé is more successful than both (has earned more money) and she is far more acclaimed. Mimi, Whitney, and Celine are Britney/Gaga/Katy level when it comes to acclaim. Even Rihanna is above them in that.
How?
Mariah and Whitney gets insane acclaim for their vocals alone. They're acclaimed lol.
And Beyonce is not more objectively successful. Singers are still public figures, there success is measured by what they have done publicly and although Beyonce has massive success there too, Mariah and Whitney's success are even bigger.
Mariah and Whitney gets insane acclaim for their vocals alone. They're acclaimed lol.
And Beyonce is not more objectively successful. Singers are still public figures, there success is measured by what they have done publicly and although Beyonce has massive success there too, Mariah and Whitney's success are even bigger.
Always switching it up to something we can't measure. More money = more success.
i can't at the Beyhive thinking all of her singles are remembered global classics.
I mean there are successful songs and then there are the legendary hits.
.
bet you don't know any female artists selling out stadiums 2 decades into their music career either.
Besides Madonna, Celine, Tina & Bey. The evergreen 4
yall want to name all of these classics, but do these classics bring all the g3rls to the stadiums yard?
NOBODY in the GP remembers ST songs sis. they bombed at radio in the first place. "Dance With You" "Get Me Bodied" and "Ego" 
too much. 
