[-mUsIcLoVeR-]

Originally posted by Pon.

Ppl don't like Lilly cuz she's an indie artist, her music is NOT mainstream

Just because someone is not as mainstream as other contestants, it doesn't mean people don't like her/him. Lilly may not be that "typical", but she's just unique, and that uniqueness Lilly possesses makes her a fan-favorite.

[Luis]

My Ideal Top 12:

01. Lacey Brown :heart:
02. Lee Dewyze
03. Crystal Bowersox
04. Siobhan Magnus
05. Didi Benami
06. Casey James
07. Michael Lynche
08. Andrew Garcia
09. Katie Stevens
10. Tim Urban
11. Paige Miles
12. Aaron Kelly

[INTRA]

Andrew is like the new Danny Gokey.


I cannot believe Alex was eliminated, and Lilly? Seriously? I love her version of "I Fall To Pieces."



Anyhow, my Top 2 would probably be Siobhan & Lacey. (Though I know Lacey won't make it that far.)

[Pon.]

Lacey is a lovely girl. but i don't think she's good enough for the competition

[Razzle]

Originally posted by migaruler

tim urban needs to be eliminated ASAP!

i agree

[gracee]

^

[tcatron565]

Originally posted by INTRA

Andrew is like the new Danny Gokey.

Um... no.

[Evan]

Originally posted by migaruler

andrew garcia needs to be eliminated ASAP!

Totally agree.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by INTRA

Andrew is like the new Danny Gokey. )

Danny was far worse.

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Originally posted by INTRA

Andrew is like the new Danny Gokey.

they are both overrated, chubby, and wearing specs. Danny's voice is better, but Andrew is a better musician.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by Carrie-is-no-1

they are both overrated, chubby, and wearing specs. Danny's voice is better, but Andrew is a better musician.

Yeah, and Danny had the WORST personality.

[tcatron565]

You people.

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by tcatron565

You people.

What's that supposed to mean? Lol. I'm just statin' my opinion, dude.

[tcatron565]

The fact that everyone's still whining about Danny Gokey. It's been a year, he didn't win. We get it, you don't like him.

[MusicTalker]

This year will be nothing like last year. The entire top 3 debuted with top 15 albums. Allison's album also was a success (sort of).

[Bad Wolf]

Originally posted by tcatron565

The fact that everyone's still whining about Danny Gokey. It's been a year, he didn't win. We get it, you don't like him.

I mean it's not as if it's irrelevant considering he just performed on Idol and released an album. I just think he's a cocky mother****er who uses his dead wife.

And I'm not whining, I just find him a HUGE douche. However, I don't find Garcia to be one at all and since they were compared I was just stating my opinion.

[fpppy]

Cyrstal Bowersox is the next American Idol. She better be anyways or i will protest this show for good.

[Bad Wolf]

I think Crystal will be this year's shock elimination. She could win it, but they're pimping her sooo early.

[NickLacheyFan]

Katie Stevens reminds me so much of JoJo, I dunno how people haven't said anything like this till now.

I also think that she def' suits JoJo's kind of music.

Didi got what it takes to win it but for some reason I think she's like too adorable and that type of the reality shows runner ups...I know it sounds crazy but I just see her going to the finals but ending up second.

I do hope she will win this.

So many stand outs this season, loves it!

[Carrie-is-no-1]

Originally posted by NickLacheyFan

Katie Stevens reminds me so much of JoJo, I dunno how people haven't said anything like this till now.

I also think that she def' suits JoJo's kind of music.

Didi got what it takes to win it but for some reason I think she's like too adorable and that type of the reality shows runner ups...I know it sounds crazy but I just see her going to the finals but ending up second.

I do hope she will win this.

So many stand outs this season, loves it!

I think Didi will end up @ like #5 like Ms Brook White!! Still, she's my Didi :heart: