[collin]

Let me guess: Amy is not a legend but Bob Marley is.

[Cap10Planet]

Yes, Bob Marley is more of a legend than Amy, that's for sure.

His music, face and family just became popular over time. He wasn't instantly called a legend because he died.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by Shaliydah88

Whitney was already a legend before she passed.

The one that people refer to as a legend that I don't understand is Mariah. Before 2012, when being an icon/legend actually meant something, I always saw her being referred to as an icon.

No one seriously think Mariah is legend. You don't become a legend by singing a bunch of forgotten, generic ballads from critically panned albums in the 90s.

[Evolution]

Amy Winehouse being a bigger legend than Bob Marley

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by collin

Let me guess: Amy is not a legend but Bob Marley is.

Why you had ruin the argument

[slobro]

This might be the worst live vocal by a pop singer (Brittany doesn't count) ever

[Shaliydah88]

Collin, you're a mess for that.

[iHype.]

Originally posted by collin

Let me guess: Amy is not a legend but Bob Marley is.

Best-Selling Albums of All-Time in US
Rank - Estimated Sales (m) - TITLE - Artist - (Year Released) RIAA
01 - 16,220,000 - METALLICA - Metallica - (1991) ▲16
02 - 15,620,000 - COME ON OVER - Shania Twain - (1997) ▲20
03 - 15,030,000 - JAGGED LITTLE PILL - Alanis Morissette - (1995) ▲16
04 - 12,660,000 - 1 - Beatles - (2000) ▲11
05 - 12,270,000 - MILLENNIUM - Backstreet Boys - (1999) ▲13
06 - 12,180,000 - THE BODYGUARD - Soundtrack - (1992) ▲17
07 - 11,920,000 - LEGEND - Bob Marley & the Wailers - (1984) ▲15
08 - 11,900,000 - SUPERNATURAL - Santana - (1999) ▲15
09 - 11,710,000 - HUMAN CLAY - Creed - (1999) ▲11
10 - 11,450,000 - 21 - Adele - (2011) ▲11

Whenwill Amy have a Diamond, best-selling all-time album over three decades after death.

Amy was a UK one album-fad like Duffy, Leona Lewis, and Susan Boyle. Please.

[Shaliydah88]

Originally posted by Gui Blackout

No one seriously think Mariah is legend. You don't become a legend by singing a bunch of forgotten, generic ballads from critically panned albums in the 90s.

Well then poor Britney.

[BlueTimberwolf]

Originally posted by slobro

This might be the worst live vocal by a pop singer (Brittany doesn't count) ever

At some point you have to know when bow out gracefully.

[bijonse]

Mariah would have to die to be considered a legend at this point, she and Madonna have done so much damage to their reputations. AT LEAST massadonna has the ultimate receipt of being the actual best selling female artist of all time (mimi always claiming to be is SUCH a ki)

[Cap10Planet]

Interesting enough, Bob Marley's streams DESTROYS Madonna's. I laugh.

[Gui Blackout]

Originally posted by slobro

This might be the worst live vocal by a pop singer (Brittany doesn't count) ever

screaming at the account being CelineDionHD

[BabyCantYouSee]

No one says most of these artists are legends. I feel like you guys are making this up.

Actual legends: Michael Jackson, Stevie Wonder, Elvis, Madonna, Aretha Franklin, Beyoncé, Mariah Carey.

[FatShady]

Originally posted by bijonse

beyonce is obviously going down as one of the greatest musicians of all time and shes only 34

she has TRUE cultural impact, her chart flops like flawless are referenced all over the ****ing place meanwhile girls out here scoring "smashes" that cant even get people to come see them live or even purchase an album. lets NOT compare GÓD to some flash in the pan casino act from the late 90s/early 2000s who cant even pick what cereal she wants to eat in the morning without a guardian

Hive lowkey sound like Britney fans.

Yes Beyonce is a big celebrity, even bigger than Rihanna but so is the Kartrashian familly so was Linday Lohan and Paris Hilton.

At the end of the day Beyonce is a one note copy cat who has never truly evolved and at best is a tribute act.

----
IASF was heavily influenced by Gaga and BEYONCE by Rihanna.

[bijonse]

literally no one would've cared about amy winehouse ever again had she not died at 27. and this is coming from someone who thinks back to black is a perfect album

[Kayhan]

Here is the thing. Everyone considers Bob Marley a legend many can't name ANY song from him lol. He is just a teenager icon at most which is why I only see him appreciated on metal cigar boxes.

[Cap10Planet]

Originally posted by Kayhan

Here is the thing. Everyone considers Bob Marley a legend many can't name ANY song from him lol. He is just a teenager icon at most which is why I only see him appreciated on metal cigar boxes.

And that's why his streaming numbers embarrass most "legends." His music is being streamed like a modern act, and I'm not exaggerating.

[FatShady]

Beyonce is a Whitney Houston type "Legend" for sure.
An "American Sweetheart" type "Legend".

[Gui Blackout]

Amy's next album would be massively successful and acclaimed just like BTB, the "fad" argument makes no sense.