[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by MJ Boston

Eh. She really doesn't. It's more that a lot of people here don't like her stans so they bash her as a result because we've grown in numbers on here - and attack their favs, etc.

oh heY.



But for realz, Imma need N&S to stay perched on these kinds of threads. She has all the receipts ready to copy and paste.

[KevinKDC]

Well that was fun..... And yes at CMB going gold

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by Ryan

Learning to expose without incurring points is everything

Shading is so easy on ATRL. It's all about how strong your WP worthy posts are that you purposely post.

[FAN]

That thread was fun, it was closed and I have the last post.

[rivers]

Why are all the Kelly threads so messy?? ATRL SEETHES when they see the basic girl slaying their faves

[Taemira]

In June, World Wide
30. “Stronger” Kelly Clarkson – 525,000* (total: 1,400,000)

1,400,000 - 525,000 = 875,000
So Stronger sold 875,000 copies during 2011
And let's see mediatrafic 2011 year end chart, http://www.mediatraffic.de/albums-2011.htm
#40 sold 1.1m copies during 2011, so Stronger could not be in Top 40

10/23/2012
“Stronger” Kelly Clarkson – 872,000 (total: 1,750,000)
And let's see mediatrafic 2012 year end chart, http://www.mediatraffic.de/albums-2012.htm
Stronger didn't sell 130,000 copies during the two months
So Stronger sold less than 1m copies (#40's sales) during 2012, Therefore Stronger could not be in Top 40

The fact that Stronger wansn't on both 2011 and 2012 year end charts of mediatraffic doesn't mean Stronger has sold less than 1.8m copies

I was about to post this
Anyway, so Stronger has sold about 1.85m copies, right?
And i used to see some stupid haters saying MDNA's sales are bigger than Stronger's

[Mr. Know It All]

Originally posted by Ryan

Learning to expose without incurring points is everything

I escaped unscathed. Skill.

[KevinKDC]

Of course..... People never talk about Kelly here, but they will talk about the lesbian rumors

[mike_10]

Originally posted by lifeofpariah

I was about to post this
Anyway, so Stronger has sold about 1.85m copies, right?
And i used to see some stupid haters saying MDNA's sales are bigger than Stronger's

Save them for the next one

[NotTonightTho]

I am not proud of some of the things I said in those threads

[Jaymz]

That Kelly vs Xtina thead was LIFE

[KevinKDC]

I don't like dragging Christina stans because I feel sad for them and I generally like Christina as a artist, but they really asked for it.....

Anyway Addicted is coming back in 3 days

[NotTonightTho]

I love Christina but her stans are just so

I had fun tho, and no WPs

[rivers]

Originally posted by NotTonightTho

I am not proud of some of the things I said in those threads

[jpsketch]

CMB going gold.

So it sold almost 70k thanks to the Voice, and almost doubled that post Christmas.

[Taemira]

Yes, Christina stans are so rude
And i always laugh at them thinking the fact that Christina is ridiculed globally means Christina is a global act who is still relevant

[NotTonightTho]

Originally posted by lifeofpariah

Yes, Christina stans are so rude
And i always laugh at them thinking the fact that Christina is ridiculed globally means Christina is a global act who is still relevant

The thing that really gets me is when they pull the Maroon 5 receipts.

[KevinKDC]

CMB sold 120k last week. That's pretty good

[MissBreakaway]

Not the fight shifting to Kelly vs. Beyoncé I don't want to mess with the Hive again...

[NotTonightTho]

The Hive scares me sometimes

I love Bey and Xtine but it seems to be international Come For Kelly Day