[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by JeremyALD

What on femme fatale is trendsetting

And considering her involvement in the creative process; aren't her producers really the ones setting the trend

Everything.

And the producers are nothing without Britney her voice, image and relevance.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by JeremyALD

What on femme fatale is trendsetting

And considering her involvement in the creative process; aren't her producers really the ones setting the trend

Kiiiiiiii don't go there

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Are you seriously forgetting about Since u been gone and hazel eyes? Let's not forget that Kelly is one of the biggest reasons why luke is so relevant right now.

And let's not forget Luke continued to grow and maintain relevance while Kelly kind of faded. His sound is much more versatile than Kelly's standard sound.

[JeremyALD]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Everything.

And the producers are nothing without Britney her voice, image and relevance.

It sold less than Stronger worldwide and Hold It Against Me faded to nothing after it's initial hype. Her most successful single was a ke$ha reject and the critical reception was lukewarm. Her digital singles totaled 6 million in the USA, LESS than Kelly Clarkson who only had one smash single. The album opened with 294K and despite two successful singles after it's release didn't surpass 800K.

She sang a song with Sabi.

I'm not trolling, I'm just stating the facts from that era. I don't see how her career has set trends after Blackout.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

Britney is a trendsetter. Something Kelly never has been and probably never will be.

Billboard disagrees http://atrl.net/forums/showthread.php?t=206769

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by JeremyALD

It sold less than Stronger worldwide and Hold It Against Me faded to nothing after it's initial hype. Her most successful single was a ke$ha reject and the critical reception was lukewarm. Her digital singles totaled 6 million in the USA, LESS than Kelly Clarkson who only had one smash single. The album opened with 294K and despite two successful singles after it's release didn't surpass 800K.

She sang a song with Sabi.

I'm not trolling, I'm just stating the facts from that era. I don't see how her career has set trends after Blackout.

Not too much sis

[jpsketch]

This is still going on.

[KevinKDC]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

And let's not forget Luke continued to grow and maintain relevance while Kelly kind of faded. His sound is much more versatile than Kelly's standard sound.

Yes she faded because she didn't breakaway from her pop/rock sound while luke followed the mainstream sound by step. That's my point since the beginning of the discussion. Kelly is still stuck in 2005.

[EdgeOfAddiction]

Originally posted by JeremyALD

It sold less than Stronger worldwide and Hold It Against Me faded to nothing after it's initial hype. Her most successful single was a ke$ha reject and the critical reception was lukewarm. Her digital singles totaled 6 million in the USA, LESS than Kelly Clarkson who only had one smash single. The album opened with 294K and despite two successful singles after it's release didn't surpass 800K.

She sang a song with Sabi.

I'm not trolling, I'm just stating the facts from that era. I don't see how her career has set trends after Blackout.

I'm not about to read Kelly downE at 2:05AM. But let it be known, FF fillers > Stronger fillers.

[rivers]

While you girls are arguing over nonsense, I'm watching Kelly's performance of Why Haven't I Heard From You from CMT Giants. What an amazing, FLAWLESS performance

She looked amazing too

[JeremyALD]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I'm not about to read Kelly downE at 2:05AM. But let it be known, FF fillers > Stronger fillers.

Too bad both albums have so many

[rivers]

Originally posted by EdgeOfAddiction

I'm not about to read Kelly downE at 2:05AM. But let it be known, FF fillers > Stronger fillers.

All you do is trash Kelly when someone else drags another artist you like. We've heard it already.

[JeremyALD]

Originally posted by KevinKDC

Yes she faded because she didn't breakaway from her pop/rock sound while luke followed the mainstream sound by step. That's my point since the beginning of the discussion. Kelly is still stuck in 2005.

Personally I haven't heard any songs on the radio like Mr. Know It All. I actually think that was a really good single and it showed in her international markets, where recently she has sparked very little interest.

[KevinKDC]

People wanting to drag their own fave everytime someone says sth negative about a artist they like... How stupid and ignorant can you be

[joelovesmusic]

lol the last few posts/pages Y'all know how to talk. Meanwhile:

[Taigan]

I actually really loved Femme Fatale. I think the concept and packaging of the whole thing was more interesting, but Stronger definitely has the better music, even filler wise. I'm sorry, there's nothing on FF that can stir up the drama like in Sun Will Rise, Dark Side, etc. or the flaming anger of LMD or just the general awesomeness of WDKY (EXCEPT Till The World Ends).

The only advantage of FF is that the music is catchier (because the melodies were constructed by pop music geniuses) and the sound is fresher (because it pursues the generic dance route, barring a couple of tracks and some new sounds incorporated by said geniuses). That is all. Oh, and let's not pretend Britney has even half the involvement that Kelly does in her work. Hmm... idk, how about writing some of the songs herself?... how about singing them live every now and then? We can't even use the excuse that Britney dances anymore.

The rest of you secret britbots can go back to that other place now. Stronger > FF

[Taemira]

Just realized that we didn't get Stronger Tour DVD
RCA

[MissBreakaway]

You just don't want to get that Kelly doesn't WANT to be a hit making mainstream puppet. She doesn't WANT to work with these producers, she wants to write songs that portray her emotion and help her through, she doesn't care about the success of it. That's what makes an artist. Kelly is far superior to Britney especially considering her versatility. But let's not go there again.

[HotDecember]

Originally posted by lifeofpariah

Just realized that we didn't get Stronger Tour DVD
RCA

If they release tour DVD, do you think how many copies it will sell? 10k copies in total?
RCA is smart enough

POP:
24 21 KELLY CLARKSON Catch My Breath 3937 3700 237 24.228
+72 Spins
+60 Bullet
+0.274 Audience

HOT AC:
12 12 KELLY CLARKSON Catch My Breath 2354 2417 -63 18.180
+14 Spins
-7 Bullet
+0.232 Audience

[Taemira]

KELLY CLARKSON - Catch My Breath : 48.506 (+1.135)

Rise up Kelly, rise. this is the beginning