Discussion: Better discography: Beyoncé vs Lady Gaga - Page 25

DirtyMind

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

As in it's not true that Mariah doesn't have more cheesy songs than Whitney, as in it's not true that Whitney stopping making cheesy music after Bodyguard. Naming 4 songs out of 3 albums proceeding Bodyguard

I was obviously comparing Whitney's cheesy material to Celine's in terms of which has more, not their sounds

Pointless to bring up Whitney growing after Bodyguard, yes she grew but nowhere near how much Mariah grew after Music Box

Hey, do you though. I'm done going back and forth over this tbh

Lmfao..whatever, the lambs live in delusion about Mariah's music.

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by DirtyMind

Lmfao..whatever, the lambs live in delusion about Mariah's music.

It's not just the lambs, non stans have voted for Mariah as well

We don't live in as much delusion as you do though.

Carey on.

DirtyMind

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

It's not just the lambs, non stans have voted for Mariah as well

We don't live in as much delusion as you do though.

Carey on.

I thought you were done?

MCBeth

Honey, if you're going to stay perched in my thread bring something new. I'm done arguing about "who has cheesier" material, like I said before and my last comment had nothing to do with that. Carey on some more

DirtyMind

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

Honey, if you're going to stay perched in my thread bring something new. I'm done arguing about "who has cheesier" material, like I said before and my last comment had nothing to do with that. Carey on some more

LMFAO! Off-key as hell!

Kool_Aid_King

Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston
Emotions

vs Whitney
Music Box vs I'm Your Baby Tonight

Daydream vs My Love Is Your Love
Butterfly vs Just Whitney...

Rainbow

vs I Look to You

Honestly, you shoulda done it by the year the year they were released (even though Nippy came earlier)...

Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston
Emotions vs Whitney
Music Box vs I'm Your Baby Tonight
Butterfly vs My Love Is Your Love
Charmbracelet vs Just Whitney...
Memoris of an Imperfect Angel vs I Look to You

Kool_Aid_King

Mariah has cheesier songs than Whitney though.

Make It Happen
Hero
Dreamlover
Forever
Always Be My Baby
Open Arms (i.e. Cheesiest song of all time)
My All
Butterfly
The Roof
Babydoll
The Beautiful Ones
When You Believe
I Still Believe
Crybaby
Against All Odds
Thank God I Found You
Can't Take That Away
Bliss
Lead The Way
Reflections (Care Enough)
Never Too Far
If We
Through The Rain
Boy (I Need You)
The One
My Saving Grace
Yours
I Only Wanted
Sunflowers
We Belong Together
Fly Like a Bird
Don't Forget About Us
Circles
Your Girl
Mine Again
Bye Bye
Love Story
I Stay in Love
I'll Be Loving You Long Time
I Wanna Know What Love Is
HATE U
Angels Cry
Inseparable
Triumphant
Almost Home

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

Mariah has cheesier songs than Whitney though.

Make It Happen
Hero
Dreamlover
Forever
Always Be My Baby
Open Arms (i.e. Cheesiest song of all time)
My All
Butterfly
The Roof
Babydoll
The Beautiful Ones
When You Believe
I Still Believe
Crybaby
Against All Odds
Thank God I Found You
Can't Take That Away
Bliss
Lead The Way
Reflections (Care Enough)
Never Too Far
If We
Through The Rain
Boy (I Need You)
The One
My Saving Grace
Yours
I Only Wanted
Sunflowers
We Belong Together
Fly Like a Bird
Don't Forget About Us
Circles
Your Girl
Mine Again
Bye Bye
Love Story
I Stay in Love
I'll Be Loving You Long Time
I Wanna Know What Love Is
HATE U
Angels Cry
Inseparable
Triumphant
Almost Home

Mariah has 10 studio albums and Whitney has 6, how is it comparable? For the same amount of material, Whitney has more

I wanna know what Love is and The beautiful ones are covers so they are not her songs

Butterfly, Always be My baby, The Roof, Babydoll, etc are not cheesy

What the actual......

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by DirtyMind

LMFAO! Off-key as hell!

I'm sorry but this thread is asking who has better discography so this is completely off topic

I'm not insecure in my fave so I won't post any performance by nippy after her voice change.

None of this matters, unless you have something to talk about regarding their materials please peacefully exit this thread without embarrassing yourself and others, thank you in advance.

Kool_Aid_King

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

Mariah has 10 studio albums and Whitney has 6, how is it comparable? For the same amount of material, Whitney has more

I wanna know what Love is and The beautiful ones are covers so they are not her songs

Butterfly, Always be My baby, The Roof, Babydoll, etc are not cheesy

What the actual......

All those songs are still cheesy though. It's not like I don't like them, I love a majority of them, but they're still filled with Queso.

All of those songs are sappy love songs.

DirtyMind

Quote:

Originally posted by MCBeth

I'm not insecure in my fave so I won't post any performance by nippy after her voice change.

Of course you won't...you can't find any performances of Whitney singing off-key like that at 29.

Soda Pop Queen

Mariah.

Pecinta Mariah

I don't know how you define cheesy guys
so I'd go

Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston
Emotions vs Whitney
Music Box vs I'm Your Baby Tonight
Daydream vs My Love Is Your Love
Butterfly vs Just Whitney...
Rainbow vs I Look to You

Cobrastyle.

Mariah

MCBeth

Quote:

Originally posted by Pecinta Mariah

I don't know how you define cheesy guys
so I'd go

This. I still don't understand how "The Roof", "Butterfly", etc are cheesy.

Honey

Mariah Carey vs Whitney Houston
Emotions vs Whitney
Music Box vs I'm Your Baby Tonight
Daydream vs My Love Is Your Love
Butterfly vs Just Whitney...
Rainbow vs I Look to You

So Mariah.

Honey

Quote:

Originally posted by Kool_Aid_King

Mariah has cheesier songs than Whitney though.

Make It Happen
Hero
Dreamlover
Forever
Always Be My Baby
Open Arms (i.e. Cheesiest song of all time)
My All
Butterfly
The Roof
Babydoll
The Beautiful Ones
When You Believe
I Still Believe
Crybaby
Against All Odds
Thank God I Found You
Can't Take That Away
Bliss
Lead The Way
Reflections (Care Enough)
Never Too Far
If We
Through The Rain
Boy (I Need You)
The One
My Saving Grace
Yours
I Only Wanted
Sunflowers
We Belong Together
Fly Like a Bird
Don't Forget About Us
Circles
Your Girl
Mine Again
Bye Bye
Love Story
I Stay in Love
I'll Be Loving You Long Time
I Wanna Know What Love Is
HATE U
Angels Cry
Inseparable
Triumphant
Almost Home

Dead at the bolded songs being 'cheesy'.

Did you look at Mariah's discog and choose every other song?

MCBeth

Now: Mary J. Blige vs Toni Braxton

What's the 411? vs Toni Braxton
My Life vs Secrets
Share My World vs The Heat
Mary vs Snowflakes
No More Drama vs More Than a Woman
Love & Life vs Libra
The Breakthrough vs Pulse

Already done

MCBeth

What's the 411? vs Toni Braxton
My Life vs Secrets
Share My World vs The Heat
Mary vs Snowflakes
No More Drama vs More Than a Woman
Love & Life vs Libra
The Breakthrough vs Pulse

Mary: 4
Toni: 4

Tied

atrlster