Oop. Just saw the 60 on metacritic. The website still says three and a half stars, so it's possible they could just be confused and haven't verified it yet. I suggest tweeting to Billboard for verification.
There was some confusion earlier as to it was 3 or 3.5 (it was showing up differently for some people). I guess MC took the 60 one which makes no sense because it's an overall positive review. Are they pressed over the time Gags dragged them?