[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by Duca

1. Mary The Night 3/5
2. Born This Way 4.5/5
3. Government Hooker 2/5
4. Judas 5/5
5. Americano 1/5
6. Hair 4/5
7. Scheiße 5/5
8. Bloody Mary 3/5
9. Bad Kids 3.5/5
10. Highway Unicorn 1.5/5
11. Electric Chapel 4/5
12. Yoü And I 2.5/5
13. Heavy Metal Lover 3.5/5
14. The Edge Of Glory 4.5/5

OVERALL: 3.5/5 The standouts are strong, but the low points are tragic.

"Scheiße" must become a single. "Hair" and "Electric Chapel/Heavy Metal Lover" would make good singles too.

"Bloody Mary" & "Americano" deserve more love.

I though you hated "Born This Way" (song) , It really grew on you, didn't it?

Is it better than TF / TFM?

[Baby Judas]

Originally posted by Duca

[*]Americano 1/5

[Allstar]

It looks like Americano is the song that splits everybody.
Some love it some hate it.

I noticed something bad in the production of Yoü And I but I just hope it's not like that on the album and it's because of the quality.

[Darren-5-08]

Originally posted by Chris101

LADY GAGA - The Edge Of Glory: 23.504 (+ 1.617)

I'm so glad that this is climbing sensibly

I have concluded a few things about the album:
-> I love every song
-> Scheiße is the best song
-> Scheiße, MTN and TEOG are potential WW #1s
-> I just wanna be free, I just wanna be me! is my favourite line of the entire album
-> This is my all-time favourite album.

[nky0411]

What ??!! Americano 1/5 ...

Americano deserves at least 3/5 ... LOL

[Duca]

Originally posted by Chris101

"Bloody Mary" & "Americano" deserve more love.

"Americano" is downright awful, while "Bloody Mary" is a borefest.

Originally posted by Chris101

I though you hated "Born This Way" (song) , It really grew on you, didn't it?

I really like it, besides the bridge.

Originally posted by Chris101

Is it better than TF / TFM?

Definitely better than "The Fame," not sure about "The Fame Monster." It's certainly not as bad as it seemed on first listen.

[Allstar]

I still don't know what to take as an avi.

Originally posted by Duca

"Americano" is downright awful, while "Bloody Mary" is a borefest.
Definitely better than "The Fame," not sure about "The Fame Monster." It's certainly not as bad as it seemed on first listen.

It will grow on you and you will learn to appreciate my Americano.

[Duca]

Originally posted by Darren-5-08

I'm so glad that this is climbing sensibly

I have concluded a few things about the album:
-> I love every song
-> Scheiße is the best song
-> Scheiße, MTN and TEOG are potential WW #1s
-> I just wanna be free, I just wanna be me! is my favourite line of the entire album
-> This is my all-time favourite album.

Agreed.

I don't like "Mary The Night." "Government Hooker" was the most disappointing song IMO, it sounded amazing in that preview.

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by Darren-5-08

I'm so glad that this is climbing sensibly

I have concluded a few things about the album:
-> I love every song
-> Scheiße is the best song
-> Scheiße, MTN and TEOG are potential WW #1s
-> I just wanna be free, I just wanna be me! is my favourite line of the entire album
-> This is my all-time favourite album.

1. I agree. (Except the bonus tracks, I like those)
2. "Bloody Mary" is. And it probably is the fan-favourite.
3. MTN & TEOG, yes. Scheiße, I don't know, it needs an edit. I would replace Scheiße with Americano.
4. I want his whisky mouth all over my blood south is mine. Even though the line you picked is also great and the best in Hair.
5. Yup.

[J a y]

Heavy Metal Lover

[Baby Judas]

Yoü And I deserves to be released as a single..


This will surely smash!!! Something new- compared to Gaga's previous singles..

[Duca]

Originally posted by Allstar

It will grow on you and you will learn to appreciate my Americano.

I'm never listening to that again.

[Darren-5-08]

Originally posted by JRtheMonster

VOTE FOR GAGA AT THE MUCHMUSIC VIDEO AWARDS!

I think we should all tweet this! Especially Jay, and if someone can get tobeymonster and GaGaInfo, that would be brilliant!

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Haus_of_Jay

Heavy Metal Lover

I love when you post so suddenly and unexpected about a song.

[FreeBitch]

Originally posted by Baby Judas

Yoü And I deserves to be released as a single..


This will surely smash!!! Something new- compared to Gaga's previous singles..

THIS !!!

[Duca]

Originally posted by Chris101

3. MTN & TEOG, yes. Scheiße, I don't know, it needs an edit. I would replace Scheiße with Americano.

I think "Mary The Night" would flop. "Scheiße" would smash hard. It should have been the second single.

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by Duca

"Americano" is downright awful, while "Bloody Mary" is a borefest.



I really like it, besides the bridge.



Definitely better than "The Fame," not sure about "The Fame Monster." It's certainly not as bad as it seemed on first listen.

- You will learn to appreciate those. Hopefully they grow on you, especially BM.

- Really? I think the bridge is the best part of the song.

- Yeah, it's a grower especially tracks like Bloody Mary, Electric Chapel, Highway Unicorn, Marry The Night etc.

[Allstar]

Originally posted by Duca

I'm never listening to that again.

You will not be able to avoid it as soon as it becomes a single and the video will be the continuation of Telephone together with Beyoncé.

[Chrïs.]

Originally posted by Duca

I think "Mary The Night" would flop. "Scheiße" would smash hard. It should have been the second single.

I think "Marry The Night" along with "Hair" & "You and I" are the only left commercial songs on the album. Maybe "Highway Unicorn" and "Americano" also. So, I doubt that will flop.

I don't know about "****". They need to edit those German parts.

"Americano" and "Hair" are the safe hits from the album. "Hair" is catchy, and "Americano" will do really well WW. ***Looks at "Alejandro"***

[J a y]

Originally posted by Allstar

I love when you post so suddenly and unexpected about a song.

Just contributing

I don't like Americano, and I think I've made up my mind on that .