[freaksgeeks]

Originally posted by Onen

If pitchfork trashed MDNA, what do you think is gonna happen when they review Nickis album? Seriously, come on.

You're right, but I'm convinced that it won't be dragged. Maybe a 6.

[zach]

Originally posted by Willy.

69.

*gigles*

(not at it's score, the number)

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by madonnas

Most of the critics agreed that Cannibal is better than FF and TD, hence Cannibal being in the 70s and the other two... not being that high.

Cannibal got 11 critics vs FF's 25. Can't really compare. They're also just 6 points apart.

TD is another story.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

Cannibal got 11 critics vs FF's 25. Can't really compare. They're also just 6 points apart.

TD is another story.

6 points is a pretty big difference, but you have a legitimate point about the 11 vs 25.

[Parks]

Originally posted by madonnas

Well, they gave Beez in the Trap "best new track," but I don't think they'll like the pop half at all. I'm unsure.

A lot of reviewers liked the first four tracks on the album—I figure Pitchfork will too. Still betting on them dragging the **** out of the rest of the album just like most everyone else has.

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by madonnas

6 points is a pretty big difference, but you have a legitimate point about the 11 vs 25.

Well if one review can throw this album back down 14 points, any of the missing 14+ reviews for Cannibal could have put it down with Animal (54). 67 for FF isn't bad. You saying "not that high" makes it seem so.

[RatedG²]

It's worse than TD...nooooooooooo

[Amaru]

I don't think Pitchfork will go too hard on Nicki score-wise, but I wouldn't expect a kind review from them. They like BITT, and gave PF a 6.5. I could see them trashing PF:RR but giving it a neutral (5) to save face just as they did with the Lana De Rey and BTD situation.

Of course, I could be wrong. I guess we'll know tomorrow.

[RatedG²]

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

Well if one review can throw this album back down 14 points, any of the missing 14+ reviews for Cannibal could have put it down with Animal (54). 67 for FF isn't bad. You saying "not that high" makes it seem so.

I wonder if she'll get a complete 0 like Gaga did and bring down the average to the 30s

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

Well if one review can throw this album back down 14 points, any of the missing 14+ reviews for Cannibal could have put it down with Animal (54). 67 for FF isn't bad. You saying "not that high" makes it seem so.

Well, I was saying it wasn't very high compared to Cannibal. But I do digress that you are right about the amount of reviews for both.

I was honestly surprised FF got such a high score compared to Blackout.

[Lil Misty]

All the TD hate tsk tsk. If you read the critics reviews they're really dumb looking on it know. One said "If you heard the two singles then you have heard the best TD has to offer" Really? Really? California Gurls? Really! Plus all her other singles smashed which multiple critics said wouldn't happen.

Okay back to PF:RR
Like I said, you guys should judge more by the user score then the critics. Even then a 5.3 eek

[Stephen]

I'm excited for Pitchfork's review.

[Rico Shameless v2]

Originally posted by RatedG²

I wonder if she'll get a complete 0 like Gaga did and bring down the average to the 30s

At this point..

Originally posted by madonnas

Well, I was saying it wasn't very high compared to Cannibal. But I do digress that you are right about the amount of reviews for both.

I was honestly surprised FF got such a high score compared to Blackout.

Yeah. Sadly so many of those reviews brought her life into it. First 3-4 paragraphs would be about VMAs, court then 3-4 sentences about the album highlights.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Rico Shameless v2

At this point..



Yeah. Sadly so many of those reviews brought her life into it. First 3-4 paragraphs would be about VMAs, court then 3-4 sentences about the album highlights.

To be fair, it was kinda hard to ignore it, but I think most people looking back will realize how good it is. It's 4 and a half years old, and has aged much better than Femme Fatale after just turning one year old.

[EOMM92]

Originally posted by RatedG²

I wonder if she'll get a complete 0 like Gaga did and bring down the average to the 30s

Giving an album a score of "0" is completely unprofessional, a 10 out of 100 would make the point clear without making it look like a personnal issue from the reviewer..

[DvnR]

This is so upsetting. This album may draw concerns of being generic, but it's really not bad.

[fridayteenage]

Originally posted by Lil Misty

If you read the critics reviews they're really dumb looking on it know. One said "If you heard the two singles then you have heard the best TD has to offer." Like I said, you guys should judge more by the user score then the critics. Even then a 5.3 eek

Well, Teenage Dream got a 60 from users vs. a 53 from critics. So according to you we should trust that TD deserves a 60.

[madonnas]

NOOO!
I wanted a Pitchfork review tonight.

[DTR_B]

The ****ing critics, i'm gonna get them!!!

[Will_]

I love the album but since these "critics"
don't like it I won't listen to it anymore because
I value their opinion more than my own.