[Mezik]

I don't know how Carrie is so low, especially when she's had higher MetaCritic scores then Katy, Rih, etc.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by Mezik

I don't know how Carrie is so low, especially when she's had higher MetaCritic scores then Katy, Rih, etc.

Because the major critics don't include her on end of the year lists much.

And change of plans, it'll probably happen 10ish PST, I'm leaving home in an hour and thats not enough time.

[atrlster]

Originally posted by DullEnlightenment

#31



Christina Aguilera:

Albums:

Back to Basics: Q #47 (3), EW #80 (3) = 6

Songs:
Beautiful: Pazz &Jop #28 (5) = 5
Dirty: Slant #62 (3) = 3
Ain’t No Other Man: Pitchfork #32 (5), Rolling Stone #18 (8), Pazz & Jop #3 (10), Spin #3 (10) = 33

Metacritic: -6

TOTAL: 41

I just looked around and if this site isn't mistaken, Back To Basics is #60 on the Pazz & Jop Album list that year.

http://rateyourmusic.com/list/liethu...2006__albums_/

Moves Like Jagger is also #51 on last last years Singles list

http://www.villagevoice.com/pazznjop/singles/2011/

So that should be another 11 points for her?

[madonnas]

Originally posted by atrlster

I just looked around and if this site isn't mistaken, Back To Basics is #60 on the Pazz & Jop Album list that year.

http://rateyourmusic.com/list/liethu...2006__albums_/

Moves Like Jagger is also #51 on last last years Singles list

http://www.villagevoice.com/pazznjop/singles/2011/

So that should be another 11 points for her?

Ugh can we please not do this? The site I used didn't have B2B on it. MLJ is there but well its just too late for that

[atrlster]

Originally posted by madonnas

Ugh can we please not do this? The site I used didn't have B2B on it. MLJ is there but well its just too late for that

What site did you use?
And sorry, not trying to be picky or anything Was just surprised Back To Basics didn't have more points.

[madonnas]

Originally posted by atrlster

What site did you use?
And sorry, not trying to be picky or anything Was just surprised Back To Basics didn't have more points.

http://www.robertchristgau.com/xg/pnj/pjres06.php

It's hard to find full lists, and I looked on multiple ones so i used what I found.

I might edit it in after the countdown is done, but as of right now I'm just too damn lazy to go back and switch her and Avril's positions.

[atrlster]

Originally posted by madonnas

http://www.robertchristgau.com/xg/pnj/pjres06.php

It's hard to find full lists, and I looked on multiple ones so i used what I found.

I might edit it in after the countdown is done, but as of right now I'm just too damn lazy to go back and switch her and Avril's positions.

Oh yeah, I understand.

Have you seen this site though?
http://www.rocklistmusic.co.uk/village2000.htm
http://www.rocklistmusic.co.uk/

They don't have full lists of everything, but they're pretty comprehensive

[DullEnlightenment]

Ok who cares. It's starting again now.

[madonnas]

#20



Nelly Furtado:
Albums:
Whoa, Nelly: Q n/o (3), Slant #165 (8) = 11
Loose: Q #55 (3) = 3

Songs:
I’m Like a Bird: Pazz & Jop #46 (5), Spin #19 (8) = 13
Turn Off the Lights: Pazz & Jop #54 (3) = 3
All Good Things (Come to an End): Q #65 (2) = 2
Powerless (Say What You Want): Slant #190 (3) = 3
Promiscious: Pitchfork #80 (3), Rolling Stone #56 (3), Pazz & Jop #6 (10), Slant #4 (10) = 27
Maneater: Pitchfork #59 (3), Pazz & Jop #20 (8), Slant #2 (10) = 21

Metacritic: 11

TOTAL: 94

[Jabril]

[primo.]

Is this thread the result of the extensive research you were doing the other night, Madonnas?

[madonnas]

Originally posted by primo.

Is this thread the result of your extensive research, Madonnas?

Obviously.

[Stephen]

The picture

[ImpressiveInstant]

Parking Lot should've been among all these songs. Jesus what a BOP

[Honey]

Mariah's not out yet?

[primo.]

Originally posted by madonnas

Obviously.

Are Kelis or Erykah perched anywhere on the list?

[Mr. Crabs]

Nelly shouldve been place higher, Whoa Nelly was the best album last decade

[madonnas]

Originally posted by primo.

Are Kelis or Erykah perched anywhere on the list?

I kind of forgot about Erykah, Mariah, and Cassie's existence while compoiling it. When it's done I'll compile their points and place them in here. Maybe LIl' Kim too?

[Hunter_13]

Nelly

[DullEnlightenment]

#19



P!nk:

Albums:
M!ssundazstood: Pazz & Jop #47 (8)
Try This: Q #44 (3)

Songs:
There You Go: Pazz & Jop #80 (3)
Get This Party Started: Pazz & Jop #5 (10)
Don’t Let Me Get Me: Pazz & Jop #33 (5)
Just Like a Pill: Pazz & Jop #87 (3)
Stupid Girls: Slant #8 (10)
U+Ur Hand: Rolling Stone #87 (3)
So What: Rolling Stone #29 (5), Pazz & Jop #19 (8) = 13
Please Don’t Leave Me: EW #17 (5)
Raise Your glass: EW #4 (8)

Metacritic: 25

TOTAL: 96