Before that "nose dive," Aaliyah was much more successful than Mya. Mya was a complete afterthought, and was not apart of that "trinity." She came years later.
Well, she still has air flowing through her nostrils so I guess it's clear who wins this.
Mya is definitely the Pink. Aint NOBODY remember that bitch.
Pepce really was something back then. She really killed all the r&b gurls careers with Loca (L) in Love except Alopecia (and legends like Mary J. & Mariah of course). She kind of killed J. Low too until AI revived her courier.