Averages:
Album 1: 6.88 (Highest score: 11 / Lowest: 3 [x2])
Album 2: 6.71 (Highest score: 10 [x2] / Lowest: 3)
Album 3: 4.07 (Highest score: 8 / Lowest: 1)
Album 4: 3.93 (Highest score: 7 / Lowest: 1 [x2])
I think I was a bit harsh on the two albums I really love here to balance out my two lower scoring albums, but I'm still quite surprised these averages are even this close.
There's definitely something lost in the "assign every song a number and average it out" format for grading albums but w/e.