[RihMark]

Originally posted by satellites™

She looked great.

Sounded great.

And ******* on everyone this night so they need to quit hating.

I cant even believe you. The fact that you say Rihanna cant sing is disgusting. Tiah was COMPLETELY off pitch throughout the song.

[crazychrisr92]

Simone and Tiah need to go...

[tj hazuki]

MELANIE :ALEXZ:

[DrunkNHotBoyz]

OMG @ that note. Yikes.

[satellites.™]

Oh **** my life! SING THIS **** MELANIE!

[ManDown]

She gives me Jennifer Hudson teas in the best way possible.

Damn, she's ****ing KILLING this song.

[Shy Boy]

Could Simon could have given her a more cliche song?

[Navin]

Melanie... Wow.

[Taste of Honey]

Rachel and Simone.

[@michael]

This bitch *****.

[Kh-Loud]

This gurl is soo overrated...................... her voice is soo basic.

[RihMark]

Katharine McPhee's performance on Idol>>>>>>>>.

[Ryan]

Nicole wishes she could sing like this. Effortless note from Melanie.

[ManDown]

*waits for LA and Nicole to say "WOW SIMON, SO PREDICTABLE~~"*

[Belle]

Melanie doing justice.

[crazychrisr92]

This performance

[IWasHere]

She sounds okay but she should never pick a Whitney song again. Her voice is too weak

[Queen Xtina]

AND THE PERFORMANCE OF THE NIGHT GOES TO.................MELANIE

[Navin]

Originally posted by crazychrisr92

Simone and Tiah need to go...

Bitch take Simone because that performance was dreadful, but the baby singing bitch needs to leave!

[RihMark]

Originally posted by ManDown

She gives me Jennifer Hudson teas in the best way possible.

Damn, she's ****ing KILLING this song.

She's good, but her voice has no layers. JHud's is more rich and powerful.