Quote:
Originally posted by Chivas
You could create criteria that factor in both absolute change and relative change that applies to all songs. Madonna's change is clearly more drastic than Gaga's was or any of those songs with minimal AI, and the record should reflect that.
Olympic records are based on gender AND they are also based on age since participants who are really young are not able to compete since they'd have a significant advantage over older athletes. That's actually exactly like songs having too small AI not being able to hold the record for largest percentage change because it's too easy for them to achieve large percentage changes.
Thanks for giving me the Olympics example to help me prove my point
|
Ok, Olympics wasn't the best example. Reason why there is separate records for genders is different than in this case. And age restrictions is more based on medical factors not advantages, because not in all cases too young age gives you advantage(like weightlifting).
The point is while you can't provide objective criteria that i based both on on absolute and relative change and can be applied to all songs eventually, there is no point to tell that Madonna has record.
PS. I clearly understand that Madonna is more affected by AI decrease than Gaga.