[Starkboy]

Originally posted by dwuw

Heaven On Earth?

that or Ooh Ooh Baby. Awful.

Freakshow has some good parts, some terrible. Mediocre overall.

Oh Break The Ice kinda goes in

[Prismy]

Originally posted by dwuw

Heaven On Earth?

[Stark]

Originally posted by Prismatic

Who can give that a 10?

[conatus]

I will not stand for Ooh Ooh Jesus slander.

[Superiore]

Ooh ooh baby touch me and I come alive..



When will Womanizer aka OOB's little ugly sister?

[Icarus]

There's too much Blackout stanning in here, if it gets the highest album average

These tasteless ATRLers better not pay B'day dust

[jomarr]

GGGB is trash.

It's like Rihanna released three mixtapes then flourished with her debut album Rated R.

#R5 is coming I'm so excited.

[Almighty Gaga]

Since when does Rehab feature Justin Timberlake?

[conatus]

Originally posted by IcarusIsFlying

There's too much Blackout stanning in here, if it gets the highest album average

These tasteless ATRLers better not pay B'day dust

Don't worry, those of us with taste and/or self-respect recognise B'Day > Blackout.

[jomarr]

Originally posted by Almighty Gaga

Since when does Rehab feature Justin Timberlake?

Was to point this out as well. He was in the MV but he didn't sing anything.

Can't really blame Prismatic since he's credited on the charts and on wikipedia. That's really BS.

[Stark]

Originally posted by IcarusIsFlying

There's too much Blackout stanning in here, if it gets the highest album average

Right?

I had never given out a 0 in a rate till Blackout

[jomarr]

Originally posted by conatus

Don't worry, those of us with taste and/or self-respect recognise B'Day > Blackout.

Filler'day can take several seats

[Stark]

Metacritic
The Fame Monster - 78
Good Girl Gone Bad - 72
B'Day - 70
Blackout - 61

Poor it.

[conatus]

As far as I know, Justin did background vocals (?) but he's not credited on the album or anything. Trust me, if his involvement on the song was more than that, it would NOT be getting a 10 from me.

Edit: Credited as OTHER THAN a writer/producer. Don't @ me!

[Almighty Gaga]

I only have B'Day left and I'll send in my rate.

It was a struggle going through Blackout, but I made it alive.

[Almighty Gaga]

Originally posted by conatus

As far as I know, Justin did background vocals (?) but he's not credited on the album or anything. Trust me, if his involvement on the song was more than that, it would NOT be getting a 10 from me.

He's credited as a writer and producer.

[conatus]

Originally posted by Almighty Gaga

He's credited as a writer and producer.

I know, I meant as a featured artist!

[°ColdFire°]

Originally posted by dwuw

Metacritic
The Fame Monster - 78
Good Girl Gone Bad - 72
B'Day - 70
Blackout - 61

Poor it.

But the Blackout won EMA for the Best Album of 2008 & International Album of the Year at the 2008 NRJ Music Awards

When will the rest

[MarryTheMonster]

Originally posted by conatus

Don't worry, those of us with taste and/or self-respect recognise B'Day > Blackout.

Not in this rate too Connie

[Stark]

Originally posted by °ColdFire°

But the Blackout won EMA for the Best Album of 2008 & International Album of the Year at the 2008 NRJ Music Awards

When will the rest

The Fame Monster won an IFPI Platinum Europe Award, a GRAMMY for Best Pop Vocal Album + nominated for AOTY and an Oye! award for AOTY.

+ was nominated for more awards.

B'Day won a GRAMMY for Best Contemporary R&B Album.

GGGB won an IFPI Platinum Europe award + a Juno award for International Album Of The Year. Umbrella won a Grammy.