[Dom]

Can I do Pixie Lott Discography Rate?

[Sanctuary]

What about a "Best (metacritic score) of the Gay Icons" rate?

Confessions v. Fever v. The Fame Monster v. Oops!...I Did It Again

55 songs and a whole lot of rabid fanbases involved, it could be fun. I'd actually consider replacing Oops with Blackout (even though it's not her highest metacritic score), since it seems like Brit would be the odd one out otherwise.

[Evun]

I want to host another rate but I dunno what I should do.

Is the next This Was... critical acclaim rate open?
Would a punk rate flop too much to be worthwhile?

I'll think of something.

[Dream]

Originally posted by GarageGlamorous

What about a "Best (metacritic score) of the Gay Icons" rate?

Confessions v. Fever v. The Fame Monster v. Oops!...I Did It Again

55 songs and a whole lot of rabid fanbases involved, it could be fun. I'd actually consider replacing Oops with Blackout (even though it's not her highest metacritic score), since it seems like Brit would be the odd one out otherwise.

Oh this one sounds like it would be a lot of fun

[SebaMonster]

I want to do a Nicki Minaj Discography Rate...

[Regina George]

Since The Battle of the boy bands was a BIG FLOP, I came up with a new idea

The Golden Boys Singles Rate: Biebs vs 1D vs JB
and maybe vs The Wanted, what do you think Ace?

[MP2K]

Originally posted by Regina George

Since The Battle of the boy bands was a BIG FLOP, I came up with a new idea

The Golden Boys Singles Rate: Biebs vs 1D vs JB
and maybe vs The Wanted, what do you think Ace?

That'd be a success, I don't see how it couldn't.

[Regina George]

Originally posted by MP2K

That'd be a success, I don't see how it couldn't.

Right? Now all the fans of Jonas are back, it will be interesting

[supaspaz]

Originally posted by Regina George

Since The Battle of the boy bands was a BIG FLOP, I came up with a new idea

The real boy band rate is still to come, hosted by yours truly.

[Regina George]

Originally posted by supaspaz

The real boy band rate is still to come, hosted by yours truly.

Which one? Should I start with NKOTB vs NSYNC vs BB and then the 1D vs TW vs BTR?
I still prefer the Golden boys over The battle of the boy bands

[Regina George]

I C U Ace, what do you think?

[MP2K]

When should/will This Was 2012 start? I think it will take about maybe six weeks to get voting done, maybe more idk.

[jomarr]

Ace please reply to me Even if it's in June I don't care I just want a date for the Coldplay Videography Rate

[SebaMonster]

Originally posted by SebaMonster

I want to do a Nicki Minaj Discography Rate...

[Achilles.]

Re-pitching my idea for a rate of songs that have won multiple Grammy awards since 1990 since I don't remember you saying anything about it the last time, Ace.
If we include all of the songs, it's 71... But most are classics/ big hits and we could take out a few of the lesser known songs if we really needed to.

[rawwritsmikey]

Originally posted by jomarr

Ace please reply to me Even if it's in June I don't care I just want a date for the Coldplay Videography Rate

Originally posted by Ace Reject

Jomarr - April 1st is fine.

[Jeiboy]

Good sis Ace, can I do an "ATRL's Top/Best 100 Album Title-Tracks?" or Top 50 would do? What do you think?

I'm really stoked about this!

[WayTooHonest13]

Ace, i have my taylor rate ready to go and i'm going to post it within the hour.
If you have any objections "Speak Now"

[BLaCKPoWeR]

Ace, I just came up with the BEST idea ever OMG.

50/45/40/30/25 (that can be decided later) GREATEST LOVE SONGS!

Like a best love song of all time countdown, regardless of genre. Since most popular songs are about love, I think it should be narrowed down to singles only.

It would be AMAZING.

[jomarr]

Originally posted by rawwritsmikey

YASSS We can start by next week


Thx ACE

Sorry for PMing you and everything. I thought you didn't reply